Furthermore, windmilss don't really scale well, Nuclear on the other hand which is both safer and more scalable and greener would change that but right now only the Chinese seems to have realized that.
Furthermore, windmilss don't really scale well, Nuclear on the other hand which is both safer and more scalable and greener would change that but right now only the Chinese seems to have realized that.
For reference the new nuclear in the UK (Hinkley 3.2gw) is receiving a £93/mwh subsidy, offshore wind uk project Hornsea two (1.8gw)is going to get £72mwh, and the Netherlands projects are receiving a zero subsidy for ~750mw projects.
It is not going to solve our energy crisis but there are virtually no negatives to building them now, if you have a coastline you can have zero subsidy clean energy in the next 5-10yrs.
In other words, wind and solar are linear solutions to exponential problems.
I have nothing against wind or solar but the idea that wind and solar will be able to solve our energy problems is based on a political mandate, not on science or any realistic evaluation of the energy needs of the world.
Wind can't run as long as nuclear can without maintenance and the cost is also going to be higher to maintain because of the large area it occupies.
The cost of Nuclear is suffering under the lack of political support compared to alternatives.
Furthermore, alternatives are not without problems:
"The first thing he discovered is that solar panels, in fact, contain significant quantities of toxic metals like lead, chromium, and cadmium — known carcinogens — and yet no nation outside of Europe has a plan to safely dispose of them. Many could end up in waste dumps in poor communities in Asia and Africa and poison drinking water supplies.
How much solar waste is there? About 300 times more per unit of energy than there is from nuclear power.
As a result, if solar and nuclear waste from producing the same amount of electricity were stacked on football fields, the nuclear waste would reach the height of the Leaning Tower of Pisa (52 meters), while the solar waste would reach the height of two Mt. Everest (16 km)."
http://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/2017/6/22/the-case...
And here is a study debunking the idea of alternatives as a realistic alternative (I am not saying you claim they are but that was my main point)
http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2017/06/16/1610381114.full
I think in the long run this will change to renewable sources + interconnected grids (it’s always sunny / windy / geothermal / waves) somewhere.
I’m generally pessimistic on fusion, but then it would cost me my job so I’m bound to be, but is always feels like it’s “50yrs away”
The current discusison is not based on what's optimal technologically but politically and thats in not small part due to some the unfortunate overreach of parts of the environmental organizations IMO.
I am all for tough legislation but what the current toxic political climate has made it almost impossible to discuss this in any proper matter.
Even me posting on this lead to multiple downvotes. Thats just absurd.
I think nuclear is quite bad, we've got to transport / process / store nuclear waste for thousands of years. We should probably do anything we can to avoid producing this stuff.
I grew up near where a lot of the worlds nuclear waste is processed and while it does make for lots of good jobs, that last many many lifetimes, I just can't get onboard with new nuclear when it is cheaper to build interconnected grids + renewables (in the UK at least).
I would urge you to spend a little more time looking into nuclear you would be quite surprised of how wrong your view of it is.
New reactors can use used uranium which makes the problem even smaller. On top of that, the actual footprint needed to store it is absurdly small if we even had to do that.
In other words Nuclear is the safest greenest form of energy we have (greener than wind or solar etc)
Here is a good primer on some of the myths you probably believe in.
But don't take my word or even the artcles word for it. Investigate and I am pretty sure you will soon see that your belief about nuclear is misguided.
https://thoughtscapism.com/2017/11/04/nuclear-waste-ideas-vs...
Whenever this happens some people would prefer one benefit at the expense of the other, while others prefer the other benefit at the expense of the first.
At this point the choice the group will make becomes a political point of contention. No matter which benefit you prefer your preference is political.
A lot of people want to see a more decentralized world (this does not imply a world without law and order), and they prefer society moves in the direction of decentralization, cryptocurrencies are one such facet. [Off-topic, while most cryptocurrencies today are based on energy intensive PoW, this need not be the case at all, see for example the papers on Algorand, which has not yet been implemented/deployed]
On November 10, 1972 the passenger plane Southern Airlines Flight 49 was hijacked, and the hijackers at one point threatened to fly the plane in the Oak Ridge (experimental) nuclear reactor unless their demand for $10 million in cash was met. [luckily, they did not do this even after picking up the less-than-demanded amount (according to the authorities!)] They fled to Cuba, hoping Fidel Castro would allow entry, but he rejected their entry. They landed in the US again to refuel, then fled back to land in Havana, where they were arrested at gun point.
Please note that with cryptocurrencies the hijackers don't need to land at all. One can question if the hijackers really intend to crash the plane if they demand money, but that money could flow to a political organization if the hijackers are terrorists.
I assume neither of us would want to see: 1) crypto banned 2) passenger planes shot out of the sky
This presents a conflict between nuclear power and cryptocurrencies. Which would you pick? That is automatically political indeed.
There is no "the" discussion. There is a discussion consisting of commenter beliefs, and then responses challenging beliefs.
You classified some beliefs as political as opposed to technical.
Lets define 'technical' as relating to matters of fact. Lets define 'political' as relating to selection of options.
i.e. technical statements are positive statements, and political statements are normative statements.
Every technical discussion contains tradeoffs. Tradeoffs are the source of political disagreement: when the family needs a new car, the tradeoff could be price, performance, appearance,... and the husband and wife will not in general agree. The technical tradeofff generates the political difference.
In the example I gave, some people prefer cryptocurrencies, other people prefer nuclear energy, there is no objective technologically superior future. There is only the choice among viable futures. In democracy politics should belong to us all.
Nobody is censoring you (nor me!)
If I were forced to define shaming, it would be something like: a behaviour where the perpetrator(s) make an appeal to a groups supposed definitions of virtues/sins, to change the groups perception of the victim(s).
In order to identify any such thing in this thread, I first need to identify the group: hacker news users. From reading your comments I think you (wrongly) believe the cliche "we come here for technology, we dislike politics" Then I read your posts where you identify anti-nuclear ideas as political vs pro-nuclear technologies as technological. So it seems you are the one who is shaming anti-nuclear ideas.
I am not appealing to any group virtues or sins here, and if I did I would not classify "politics" as the sin, since I regularly see people discuss tradeoffs and how they feel about it.
Btw, I am not against nuclear energy in any absolute way:
we may need nuclear power for space travel, why burn it up here and now? [no, its not in nature decaying at the same rate as we use it up, in a reactor we promote radioactive decays]
research reactors are extremely important to have for scientific progress, and cryptocurrencies are very promising for humanity too, perhaps governments should simply have a clear public policy promising to neutralize any plane [passengers or not] coming too close to a reactor or surface-storage of radioactive materials: this would decrease the probability of attempted hijackings.
I think we can both agree that nuclear reactors would ideally be aneutronic, from a waste perspective, can we not focus on that instead?
If we ignore the waste threat there is still the centralized dependency threat: irrespective if it is downtime, sabotage by employees, accidents, vulnerability during war, ...
With all this on top, I think it is not crystal clear to all of us that alternative energy sources are more expensive.
There is almost no middle ground.
Nuclear waste isn't the problem you make it out to be that's the point. It's the only waste in the US which is actually safely secured, solar on the other hand isn't and it's contains plenty of toxic materials.
Furhtermore new nuclear power plants can reuse already used uranium again making the waste problem even less.
I appreciate that nuclear waste is not what it once was, but I think it is still right not to pursue nuclear when renewables are cheaper, and an interconnected grid can provide the base supply requirement by shipping power long distances.
So not sure exactly what it is you think we are seeing differently. The facts are the facts no?
So not sure why you are so adement about those inferior technologies.
If I pay one single developer for 50 years to build me all technology Google has, I still won’t get anywhere.
If you want to actually develop nuclear, you need to increase investment. By a factor of ten or more.
(Not saying Forbes is a reliable source on this particular statistic, but maybe you can find a more authoritative one if you search?)
As for scalability, I guess the argument is that wind is somewhat limited by suitable sites, whereas nuclear produces a lot of power on a small area, with fuel lasting for millenia?
Nuclear power stations of old I thought were located by seas or other large bodies of water for the cooling in an emergency, as we saw with Fukushima. I'd guess newer designed, especially things like Fusion and Molten Salt wouldn't have this same requirement and be inherently 'safer'.
Edit to say - I'd like to see Nuclear given much more attention by governments. As we aren't using a byproduct for generation (as with those used to refine whatever for bombs) we can do it in a much easier and cleaner way without the previous constraints.
It's far greener than especially solar, there is almost no waste and most of it can be reused in new reactors. Problem is that it's toxic to be pro-nucleaer in this day and age. And new reactors saftemechanism are done via physics which makes the "china syndrome" impossible.
Agree we need more investment and focus on nuclear but not holding my hopes to hight in this current political environment.