I don’t know whether this was a typographic faux pas or a defect in my particular copy.
I don’t know whether this was a typographic faux pas or a defect in my particular copy.
The typical rule is to have the inner margins that are half as wide as the outer margins, so that the two inner margins, being adjacent, visually add up to the same space as one outer margin. This is complicated by the fact that the inside of the pages are folded and vanish in the binding. In a well typeset book, this is compensated for by adding a “binding correction” to the width of the inner margins. The result is very aesthetically pleasing. It sounds like with your edition the typesetting was done independent of the binding, and hence didn’t properly account for constraints.
I had to compare it to my other paperbacks, which were all made with ample center margins to account for the stiff binding. But they didn't look nearly as nice although not due to the center margins.
In fairness, the author (Robert Bringhurst) probably didn't have final say over the paperback, at least as it was bound in final form. The binding is just too stiff for the form factor which is unusually narrow and tall for a paperback.
There are less stiff paperback bindings. Dover used to produce paperbacks with pages stitched into signatures, but that was a more expensive binding.
He could have taken the book to a different publisher!
> In fairness, the author (Robert Bringhurst) probably didn't have final say over the paperback, at least as it was bound in final form.
I’m guessing he had a LOT of influence over the printing. The paper is extremely high quality, there’s red color type every so often, etc. If there’s any book where the author would control the printing, it’s this one.
I’m guessing he’s either optimizing for a mathematically or historically “correct” ratio over the reader experience, or we’re supposed to “break in” the book more before reading:
http://booksville.blogspot.com/2009/12/how-to-break-in-new-b...
I agree. My point is that the final, bound form is probably not available for approval. The author sees and approves pages before they are bound. He probably did not have a bound paperback in his hands until the first print run. Only then could you judge how the choice of center margin did not work with the other choices.
He may have had approval over the method of paperback binding, but a number of variables are conspiring to make the final spine stiff enough that the pages kind of disappear into the binding. Some of those were the variables the author apparently approved - the paper choice, the page dimensions, the margins.
I will add that the layout really looks like a hardback layout. I think that was forefront in the author's mind.
I think you’re right that it’s about it being the correct ratio and is intended to be broken in. The copy I had as a design student certainly was.