They say they "declined to take down the archives"-- but they didn't in fact do this at all, they just insisted a request to take down the archives come in the form of a robots.txt, and they automatically and without review comply with all such requests in the form of a robots.txt. They don't in fact ever decline to take down any archives, if the request is properly given as a robots.txt.
I don't know why they bothered making statements about "declining to take down the archives" in the first place (to the journalist or to us), making comments about "Reid’s being a journalist (a very high-profile one, at that) and the journalistic nature of the blog archive" -- they did not in fact "decline to take down the archives" at all. The "journalistic nature of the archive" was in fact irrelevant. They took em down. They are down.