Does not mean "meaningless." And the purpose of shopping around is comparing between hospitals. List prices should be a good relative predictor for comparing cost.
When is the last time you dealt with any healthcare bills? This is almost universally untrue. Hospital A's list price for an MRI might be $1000, but your insurance has a deal with them where you only pay $100 out of pocket. Meanwhile Hospital B's list price for the same MRI is $500, but your insurance doesn't have a deal with them, so your OOP cost is $500. This is very common, and in many cases is impossible to know if it will happen until after you have had the procedure and are billed.
If you're checking with your insurer to find the price, then that makes the hospital's listed prices meaningless, which is the entire point of this comment chain.
In the perfect world, everyone would sit down with the hospital, look at the likely range of costs of a procedure, call the HMO/PPO to check how each outcome would be covered, and then repeat that process at several locations. But that is arduous and people don't have the time or patience.
Yes they do. Providers are already required to make their list prices publicly available, and insurance companies have it (they are already available to the general public as well, but they're probably going to be hard to find/understand for a layperson). Many insurance companies already have cost lookup tools specifically for this purpose. Posting the hospital's list price online like the article is talking about is purely for the consumption of the patient. It is not of use to the insurer.
>In the perfect world
In a perfect world, I'd contest that you wouldn't have to worry about healthcare costs at all, but I digress.
>everyone would sit down with the hospital, look at the likely range of costs of a procedure, call the HMO/PPO to check how each outcome would be covered
Except you already can do this even without looking at the list prices from a hospital. Your insurance can already tell you exactly how much you will be charged by any provider. They do not need these online 'list prices' to do so.
Every hospital charges more than the maximum reimbursable amount for the insurer. If they don't, that's because they've made a mistake - their goal is literally to set a bill that's high enough that it will generate a reimbursement for the maximum amount each time.
The problem is it's not a good predictor. I'm sure you've seen articles that say the cost of an MRI can vary between $500 and $5000. Those are the list prices.
For a given insurer, the contracted rate is probably pretty similar with the $500 rate being only marginally discounted and the $5000 rate heavily discounted.
And it will introduce price competition.
That's not how insurance works, though. You would pay 20% of your insurance's negotiated cost, not the list price. So you could still end up paying more at a hospital that has "lower prices", based on how well your insurance negotiates with them.
>And it will introduce price competition.
This is not universally a good thing.
Well first off, that's not a given. The article only mentions Medicare using price and electronic medical records as a way of 'rating' providers. I can't find anything similar about Medicare rating providers based on quality of care.
Second, look up the situation with Lasik eye clinics. Another user in this thread suggested it as a "great example of a highly functional healthcare market" driven by price competition. In reality, price competition in the Lasik market has caused eye clinics to operate more like car salesmen (complete with sales commissions, aggressive/pushy sales tactics, and deceptive marketing), and not like someone who actually has your best medical interests in mind.
I'm not saying that simply introducing price competition to hospitals will lead to something like that, but it's certainly an example of price competition not being a good thing.