Hacker News Reader

Unfortunately, Java is a poor choice to implement a programming language with and there's nothing about implementing static typing in this book. I honestly believe that most folks would be better off reading SICP or similar. What is needed is a book that can make more modern ideas (and more modern languages) accessible to industry.

View on HN

The book is more about explaining how things work and showing how they're implemented in a simple way. With this premise I think Java is a fair choice because almost everyone knows it. If you're writing a book where you're showing every single line of code of the implementation not having to explain the programming language used is a huge benefit.

Regarding type checking, I believe it wouldn't be too hard to add it to the language itself, but it would increase the page count of an already long book.

All things considered I think the book does a good job of explaining the concepts in a very accessible way without handwaving any detail.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com