Microsoft is arguing that the cheese could have been poisoned. And that people were buying less cheese because of his efforts.
Their argument is that Lundgren's product, a CD that says it's a Windows restore CD from Dell, but is actually a counterfeit produced by Lundgren in China, is (duh) a counterfeit of the Windows restore CD, which sure enough Microsoft sells for (depending on which version exactly) $25.
If you sell your cheese, saying this is a Buxton Blue, (a protected designation) but it isn't, that's counterfeiting. You have counterfeit cheese. Saying "Oh, well I saw them giving cheese away in a supermarket once, so it's free, so there shouldn't be a penalty" doesn't wash. Are you giving it away as a promotion in a supermarket? No. You're selling it, saying it's Buxton Blue. So the right question is, "How much does Buxton Blue sell for?" and the equivalent here is exactly the question Microsoft was asked, "How much do you charge for these CDs?" to which the answer is $25.
Lundgren is a counterfeiter. It's sad how many people are buying what is literally a sob story from a convicted criminal as though it's a neutral third party discussing the case.
Now you're saying the court got it right and the accused was actually selling Windows licenses. Who is right?
Lundgren couldn't sell Windows licenses any more than he could sell the Mona Lisa. He didn't have either. But he absolutely could sell a counterfeit product you can use "instead" of buying the license.
The argument that since the counterfeits are in fact worthless then the dollar amount for purposes of assessing severity is zero makes no sense. Of course the counterfeits are worthless. They're counterfeits. The law is pretty clear that the correct question is how much would the real thing be worth. It's not the court making that up, it's right in those sentencing guidelines.
Maybe the license was on a sticker on the computer, maybe it was on a broken old medium. Maybe the people got a license key from another broken computer? What do we know? Why should the court care?
From what I read (just this one article) he never claimed to provide a Windows license. If you have more information please kindly share.