I'd much rather prove a hypothesis like "a chalk circle drawn around sugar does nothing to inhibit ants" wrong, than to prove it right! That would be much more interesting!
I'd much rather prove a hypothesis like "a chalk circle drawn around sugar does nothing to inhibit ants" wrong, than to prove it right! That would be much more interesting!
How does that harm anything? The result is the result. Pretending to have a belief so it can potentially be disproven seems contrived.
Because a hypothesis is a falsifiable answer, not a question.
> I never got why this was the case; it sets the experiment up for failure:
Setting up an explanation for falsification is exactly why. But falsification isn't failure of the experiment, only the hypothesis.
Your high school self stumbled onto a serious debate in the philosophy of science of course. What I have said is fairly accepted, but if you're interested in the philosophy & arguments behind it you should read some Karl Popper[0].
But, at least at my schools, we never did any real experiment. We did demonstrations and tried to shoehorn them into the scientific method. We never started with an observation (say, mice live longer when given reduced calorie diets), worked out a hypothetical explanation for that observation, and then designed an experiment to prove or disprove our hypothesis. I’m sure that’s done at some level, but not in any science class I took.
You don't prove yourself right, you just fail to prove yourself wrong. Trying to prove yourself wrong is a much more reliable way for a human, with all our biases, to end up closer to the truth.
* mathematicians disagree