Dark themes seem to be very popular but I've always preferred light themes. I can see how dark themes would be better in the, well, dark, but I've always felt that lighter themes are easier on my eyes when I'm in a well-lit location, which is most of the time. I tend to use fairly plain color schemes as well, and although the rainbow schemes with different colors for every type of token look really cool, I tend to get distracted by them when I try them. Maybe I just haven't given them enough time, but I'm happy with my current setup!
As far as fonts, I've gotten used to Consolas, probably because it was the default font in Eclipse and that was what we used in my first comp sci class.