Is this an isolated failure, or something wrong with all MacBook Pros?
Plenty of people have. My laptop did the same thing back in January, frying two separate U2F devices (at first, I thought the key was faulty, but it fried two different keys on different ports).
I replaced the laptop and haven't thought about it since, until two days ago, when my replacement laptop fried a display adapter.
https://web.archive.org/web/20180501201626/https://discussio...
There's more evidence now, so I'm updating my prior.