Oh, and these patents shouldn't have been granted in the first place, they are design patents, and the design is right along the lines of other futuristic looking trucks that still look like trucks.
Oh, and these patents shouldn't have been granted in the first place, they are design patents, and the design is right along the lines of other futuristic looking trucks that still look like trucks.
Yes it does, the key characteristic of patent "trolling" is that the patent owner is not practicing.
I had heard of Nikola before this, because they have been featured on this site, and in other news outlets catering to EV-enthusiasts.
Many patents seem to me to be dumb, or for completely non-novel, obvious things ("one click ordering", etc), but the patent office granted them, so they are valid.
Agree they probably can't show $2B in damages, and on the fire confusion. But in any lawsuit you start off asking for way more than you'll settle for.
Because Tesla has all kinds of money to burn on lawsuits?
Meanwhile the CEO is insulting the financial community that keeps him afloat. I keep hearing how smart he is, but... sometimes...
Shell teamed up with Airflow to build the Starship prototype which will be doing a test run this year.
Sadly, functional requirements don’t trump patent filings (Apple vs Samsung) so Nikola is free to sue everyone whose aerodynamic truck design includes a curved windscreen.
Your opinion about whether these patents are valid or should have been issued is irrelevant. The Patent Office issues parents and leaves it to the courts to determine validity and worthiness.
But Nikola is clearly a real company. And they have the right to defend their IP.
I mean, apparently some large companies like Anheuser-Busch, (people who actually buy trucks) have heard of them, if they announced they are buying up to 800 of them from Nikola...
That said, I do agree that these (and a LOT of design patents) are questionable at best, but I don't have any skin in the game when it comes to the trucking industry.
It's how the game is played. so, I don't understand the anti-Nikola guys. Let's face it, if it works out their approach has some huge advantages over the 4 megawatt-hour packs the Tesla Semi is going to require.
it's all good.
and, no, Nikola is not a "patent troll" in any understanding of the words. The Branch Elonians are only slowly coming to the realization that Tesla has no sustainable advantages-- other than brand. which does have cachet. not sure that helps in Class 8 trucks, though.
For real? I read about them on this site.
I know HN gives Tesla credit for a lot, but there were and are people working on electric semis; Tesla didn't come up with the idea.
>These people are patent trolls pure and simple
(in your opinion)
Previous discussion of Nikola on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11683508
I think most people who follow electric vehicles at all seriously have heard of them.
They came up pretty regularly on HN months to a year ago. I would wager that among people who follow details of everything that happens in the EV industry the name is known.
Wait, what? "Screw you small company, -we've- never heard of you, so why should you be able to defend your patents?"