Lonava- Retrospective of a failed RealName HN/Reddit clone
e1ven.com
e1ven.com
People post to HN while hoping that pg et all will give them money- There's even more on the line then there is posting under your name.
I still think that people Would, if there were compelling enough content there to warrant the "price of admission", but since the site only works once people pay it by verifying themselves, it never builds up that unique content and discussion, so never will hit critical mass where people are willing to ID themselves to join.
People end up self-censoring about 3/4 of the things they want to say on Facebook so they don't offend anyone. It's an intellectually barren wasteland of harmless platitudes and abandoned thoughts.
I appreciate where you were coming from with this idea, but I like a little anonymity to my Internet. It's the truth spice.
One, of course, is the RealName issue, and naturally, that's where the focus of the discussion is.
The other, however, is that a site like this, RealName or otherwise, has a serious chicken-and-egg problem. You need to have a serious plan for traction before even starting. Without a built-in audience (like Joel and Jeff's readers at StackOverflow), you're fighting a seriously uphill battle to begin with.
There are 100s of these sites out there, it's just hard.
I've disabled the Real Name Verification aspects on the site- If you create an account at www.lonava.com is assumes you're verified, if anyone wanted to see how it worked.
Code is at Github.
1. Underestimate the importance of good content to attract people.
2. Overestimate the importance of real names.
3. Design. Either make it ugly (which would have been fine), or really good looking. Both your design and the designers' design where in-between meh. You should have kept it ugly and focused on the content :)
4. Pulling in feeds makes the content worse, not better. Automated content doesn't create community.
I wouldn't draw any conclusions about Real Names from this exercise, except perhaps that users don't consider them valuable enough to overcome the other frictions created by your product.