We have a local news website that I think has a realistic model. When you view an article with an ad-blocker it shows you a dialog with a variety of options:
1. Whitelist the site
2. "Nah, journalists should go hungry" - this dismisses the popup and lets you read the article with your blocker intact
3. 5c - read the article ad-free
4. 10c - 1 hour of no-ads
5. 30c - 1 day of no-ads
I've converted to US cents, but even in local currency think these prices are extremely reasonable, and I'd love to see more sites offer similar rates