That sounds like an easy solution and philosophically appealing in a libertarian sort of way.
However, it doesn't work. People can be put under enormous pressure to make the choice that satisfies others - their boss, their peers, their community, etc.; it's commonsense experience, there is a lot of research about that, and a lot of implemented practices to prevent it in safety situations. How many priests in the Catholic Church or employees at Penn State allowed child rape to continue - something which provided zero benefit - under pressure? Or remember the article posted here a few months ago about the sea captain who, apparently under pressure, sailed into a hurricane and killed his crew.
Also, people don't always make good decisions; they shouldn't die for it, we shouldn't exploit them, and we don't want a system that attracts and promotes people for making bad decisions.