All routers have some way of finding out the IP leases.
> Browser changes might break rendering of the config pages.
That's a fault in the browsers.
> The config interface is not standardized: it works for now but it will look outdated a couple of years from now. It can't be improved upon. Understanding and working with it is another annoyance that the user has to learn.
That it stays the same is a benefit, not a bad thing per se, and one could always allow for a simpler set of calls as an API to achieve functionality independent of the design.
The auth problem is definitely an issue, but more so when you expose your stuff to the whole world than to a LAN. It's next to impossible to get this right over the lifespan of a device.
Anyway, I think you really have a valid point but to me it all revolves around the security issues, the remainder depend strongly on your point of view and are not absolutes.