Generally, let's say that a gene is a stretch of DNA that encodes some functional product. That product might be a protein, or an RNA that performs some function. Think of these stretches of DNA as distinct entities that can be recognized by start and stop signals.
If you say that 55% of the genes in the human genome were already present in the first animal, then you're saying that stretches of DNA which bear a significant similarity to 55% of ours were found in the first animal.