A business has to covers its cost with the fees charged to its customers.
A municipal ISP has to cover its cost with the combination fees charged to its customers and subsidies from local government (which are charged to all citizens through taxes, whether or not they use the municipal ISP).
Not exactly an enticing business proposition to compete against a company that gets to charge your customers money whether or not they use the competitors service.
So unless the municipal ISP is so horribly inefficient that a private entity can compete with them on pricing despite the lack of subsidies, presence of a municipal ISP will lead to a municipal monopoly.
I suppose there is also the case of a municipal ISP that receives no government funding, in which case what is the point of the government here? Also, I have never heard of such an arrangement in practice so when people refer municipal ISPs, they are likely referring to government subsidized ISPs.
This ends up operating very similarly to the way CLECs have allowed 3rd party ISPs to provide DSL service. The end user has a modem that attached to the CLEC's ATM network, then a PPPoE connection transits the ATM network to the user's ISP.
With a municipal NSP, you effectively acknowledge the municipal cable plant and switching fabric as a natural monopoly, while allowing competing ISPs to provide internet transit.
Did you not read the article? EPB is a government owned company and operates at a profit. They seem to be doing a much better job providing high speed coverage to their customers than large publicly traded companies like Comcast.
I'm not against municipal ISPs, but I think government backed businesses are generally going to turn into monopolies, contrary to the parent's comment.
A grant is not (technically) a subsidy and I would suspect that the majority of ISPs building infrastructure have received federal grants in some form or another. The difference is that EPB actually provided gigabit speeds instead of taking the money and making excuses.
> I think government backed businesses are generally going to turn into monopolies, contrary to the parent's comment.
That may be true, but I think they are less likely to become monopolies when they are government owned than when then are owned by a mega-corp.
Sure, if you already have several small, privately-owned networks in your area offering gigabit speeds then introducing a municipal competitor may increase your odds becoming a monopoly dominated area. Communities like that are the outliers though and not a valid reason for state legislatures to prohibit municipality owned broadband.
The less enticing it is to be comcast the better.
The government can play a valuable role being a "competitor of last resort" in stagnant markets.
I remember when I lived in Singapore (where the government builds a large quantity of social housing at a reasonable quality), the average quality of private housing would be considered stellar elsewhere - simply because the government had set the bar so high.
No it's not. All they have to do is provide better service for a good price. Same as any other competitor.
"A business has to covers its cost with the fees charged to its customers."
Most municipal ISPs are the same.
USPS is a government agency, and even has a legally protected monopoly on first-class mail pricing, and still gets plenty of competition.
What's the point of non-subsidies municipal utilities? Accountability. It uses the structure of government to facilitate cooperative ownership.