I'm extremely skeptical of regulation that interferes with consensual deals between economic actors. You want transparency? Fine. But you don't get to randomly outlaw certain entire classes of business.
I'm extremely skeptical of regulation that interferes with consensual deals between economic actors. You want transparency? Fine. But you don't get to randomly outlaw certain entire classes of business.
Business models are arbitrary and orthogonal to services provided.
> But you don't get to randomly outlaw certain entire classes of business.
Why not? Some business models are clearly antisocial and don't deserve to exist. GDPR is only outlawing business models based on large-scale abuse of people's private and identifying information. If you can obtain proper consent from enough percentage of your users, then your business model will be fine. If that's a problem for you, then ask yourself why.
I find it funny to see people complaining that their business model will be in trouble under GDPR. GDPR literally only outlaws being a huge asshole (in context of users' data).
that doesn't change the fact that the business model depends on that orthogonal action. Is it unlawful for gyms to charge by subscription instead of per-use knowing that most people don't use them? Should the NYTimes be forced to go pay-per article instead of subscription? Should nightclubs not be allowed to overcharge the bottle?
> GDPR literally only outlaws being a huge asshole (in context of users' data).
It goes beyond that, by forcing you to serve people that don't agree to your business model.
It isn't, and it shouldn't. Either can choose whatever works for them best. GDPR only outlaws a few particular antisocial behaviours, which makes a particular class of business models illegal or much less profitable.
The "but business model!" whining sounds a bit like complaining that you can't make money mugging people, because the government disallows theft and assault. Cry me a river.
That's a very interesting claim. So you're saying it'd be possible to organize fighter jet production as a co-op vegan collective?
Maybe "orthogonal" was a bit much. But almost always there's plenty of wiggle room to choose alternative business models.
This has become the default business model of the B2C Internet, as distinct from offering a service in exchange for payment.
Either way, you don't have an inherent right to specific business models and the EU is simply not allowing a business model anymore that has been widely abused. Of course it'll hurt some but I think overall the industry will adapt and change for the better.
People want more control over how information about them is used.
For web, most people don't understand the scope of tracking and privacy. None of the people I know understand what these web companies are doing, how they are being tracked and what data companies have about them. Nobody reads the privacy notice in those websites. Even after someone tells them facebook is tracking everything, they don't understand and just ignores it. There are no consensual deals on web. So GDPR is for all of them (and for people who understand and wants protection).
Also in America a company is more important than people. That's why there are so much negativity towards GDPR.