According to Nick Lane in The Vital Question: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Vital_Question
We already know two things with certainty:
- a very small amount of material transits between Earth and Mars.
- all material on Earth contains microbes.
It would seem we also know that there are microbes on Mars, though at insignificant levels and likely not flourishing.
significantly larger, because it has to get through our atmosphere once on the way in, and then the ejecta has to do it again on the way out, keeping in mind that drag is proportional to velocity squared, and that whatever ejecta is making this trip has to find a way not to get cooked into sterility by impact energy or friction with the air....
Too many extra factors are in play, each of which adds an exponent to the unlikelihood. But that's just my uneducated opinion, I'm certainly open to discussion.
The dV to then end up on either planet doesn't matter because aerobraking and lithobraking do all the work for you.
It would be particularly exciting to discover life that is similar to Earth but with an opposite chirality, or a genetic code that encodes amino acids using different base pairs.
(I'd be thrilled to be wrong about this, of course, just as I would be fascinated with any xenobiological discovery at all. But I do think the 'endless forms most beautiful' are also strongly constrained by simple physics, and thus the solutions found by an evolutionary random walk will resemble what we already know.)
EDIT: It also makes me wonder how different an ecosystem could be. Imagine one that did not require macroorganisms eating other macroorganisms, like ones that feed on heat or wind.
EDIT 2: Maybe mating requires 3 genders, etc. There seems to be a lot of room for variation.
Invertebrates are much more relaxed about number of eyes etc.
We can go from "humans are the optimal form!", to "well, some kind of mammal", "c'mon, it's got to be a vertebrate", then get into the Cambrian experiment, go back further to different DNA (RNA anyone), then to different metabolic pathways, then to different organic biochemistry, then to non-carbon... and why should life have a chemical basis, anyway? So chemocentric.
How can we tell when he go from too anthropocentric to too anti-anthropocentric? We have guesswork only. We're like a child rebelling against its parents.
It seems to me, that elephants, dolphins, parrots, octipuses, and even spiders could have undergone the rapid brain-size increase that happened to some apes. (We don't even know why it happened to us.) They might still do so, in a few million years.
Note that some earth creatures - deep sea and underground - have almost lost eyes. Like [blind mole rats](https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Spalax). They have appropriately alien-like nose-antennae.
If there's light, they'll have eyes. Probably.