This is quite a bold claim, and one I'm not sure they're making. Their promo material suggests that it's limited to quite well-defined domains where conversations aren't really that open-ended, and we haven't seen how it'll perform in the real world.
Relatedly, I don't think headlines like "Google Duplex beat the Turing test: Are we doomed?" [0] are helpful at all. It's disappointingly low-effort clickbait where instead there's plenty of interesting discussion to be had (should machines have to identify themselves as such? What about their use of pauses and fillers?).
[0] https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-duplex-beat-the-turing-...
Is Google really saying that or just the more breathless commenters? I thought they were pretty good at making it clear that Duplex took a lot of work to do well in very constrained conversational situations.
some prominent figures in AI/ML are saying we are due for another "AI winter" since it's being oversold again.
"Some say...". Name one.
We may have a Gartner style "trough of disillusionment", but a 1990's style AI Winter is unlikely. It works too well in too many valuable areas for the money to go away.
technically Google is kind of saying they can tentatively pass the Turing Test with phones
Could you show us where they claim that? That goes well beyond any statement I've heard Google make, and into the kinds of breathless claims click-bait blogs have tried to make.
car decked out with extra sensors and 360 LIDAR cannot detect a simple stop sign with mud on it
Do you have a specific example of that? I did Google, and I couldn't fine anything.
Most examples I've seen handle occulted road signs pretty well. There are of course adversarial examples which are an interesting case, but mud causing a failure like this is surprising to me.
There were plenty of interesting results in AI research before the last two AI winters.