Often, it is difficult to take a step back and take another long hard look at what the evidence is.
The point of my mentioning "what is a photon?" is that we make certain assumptions (as per your operators, uncertainty principle, etc) which we don't step back from and see if there are alternatives. Even trying to get a handle on what the uncertainty principle means gets us into a philosophical quagmire. Our view of the "quantum realm" is coloured by a huge amount of background assumptions, including the "intuitions" of those investigating the subject matter.
There is an oft stated saying: "The science is settled" over some matter or another. Yet, the whole point of scientific endeavour is that it is not settled, we are still investigating (or at least should be).