Problem - the organization most benefited by DAFs seem not to be charities, but Vanguard/Fidelty/etc that take management fees for the DAF for the next 10 years. Just running a ballpark with 4% interest and a 1 percent total management fee, putting 500k into a DAF makes the manager about 70k, and grows the fund about 170k. Not bad, but the benefit goes almost entirely to the fund manager.
Problem - Giving to organizations is deferred to a later point in time, leading to grander visions. Theoretically, this should result in charities in the future receiving large checks, which is good. One problem with this, however, is that as numbers being donated get larger, it seems that charitable giving becomes more 'results' or 'mission' oriented. People give big chunks to bigger picture, systemic problems like curing cancer, fighting climate change, etc. These are good things. But the charities working on day-to-day problems get marginalized. My argument is certainly not that we should look for structural fixes to problems like pandemics, homelessness, or institutional racism. But a society that only gives to research universities to look for cures for pediatric cancer, and doesn't also help fund something like St. Jude, is a society with deep problems.
DAFs have significant advantages and good things. But perhaps we have, as an American society, gone the wrong way to give incentives to high-net-worth individuals to give mainly to big causes, and not to day-to-day problems.