Maybe, but the second person plural possessive is way easier with the former. Y'all's vs, what, you guys'? When I lived in the midwest I frequently heard "your guys's", which doesn't exactly roll off the tongue.
Using the yooper "You's guys" boosts your IQ by about 50 points btw - a proven fact.
"Guys" isn't gender neutral though.
Its modern usage is largely neutral, especially in "you guys". I hear both women and men refer to groups of either women or men using "you guys" or "hey guys".
I mean...you can just say "you all" which is what "y'all" is supposed to abbreviate.