Hacker News Reader

Comment by NLips | Hacker News Reader

I'll agree that the way you think of ABS should be unlike how you think of cruise control, but you shouldn't lump it in with automatic braking or adaptive cruise control. You just never need to think about ABS. It removes the need for the driver to weigh up how much or how fast to pump the breaks in an emergency situation, meaning that if you need to stop, you just slam the pedal, as it should be.

Conceptually, ABS means that the driver has a simple interface to make the car behave simply on the road. The other driver aids you mention give the drive a simple interface to make the car behave in a _complex_ way on the road, which is very different. The fact that there are smarts in the implementation is neither here nore there.

The same applies to other electronic stability packages introduced 25-20ish years ago which prevent / encourage skids depending on circumstances.

View on HN

> You just never need to think about ABS. It removes the need for the driver to weigh up how much or how fast to pump the breaks in an emergency situation, meaning that if you need to stop, you just slam the pedal, as it should be.

Maybe if you learned to drive with ABS in mind.

I had to do an emergency brake on the autobahn in Germany a couple of months ago. I instinctively did not slam the brake pedal all the way, and tried to do a controlled brake from a very high speed to a full stop. I just made it and the ABS didn't engage.

Is it really recommended to let ABS take over even from very high speeds?

If you're making an emergency stop, that is, you need to stop fifteen seconds ago, then yes, you're better off just slamming the breaks and letting the ABS do its thing. If you are not a highly trained stunt driver, I'd bet that its better at not locking the wheels then you are.

If you have more time then that, feel free to do a controlled brake and coast to a stop.

Regarding the learning to drive: I'd highly recommend taking your daily driving car to a defensive driving type course that includes a skid pan. That way you can experience what your car feels like during an emergency break, with ABS, during hydroplaning in a safe environment. This is something that could literally save your life, because you won't be surprised by how your car feels when it happens on the road.

> Regarding the learning to drive: I'd highly recommend taking your daily driving car to a defensive driving type course that includes a skid pan. That way you can experience what your car feels like during an emergency break, with ABS, during hydroplaning in a safe environment. This is something that could literally save your life, because you won't be surprised by how your car feels when it happens on the road.

This is mandatory to get a licence in some jurisdictions. Including experiencing the effect of tire wear, and having the best tires front/back.

What's the alternative? Can you jiggle the brake pedal in such a way to maximize brake power without the ABS kicking in?

Another thing to note is that, especially on good grip conditions, an ABS emergency brake can be less effective than a non-ABS one. A motorcycle instructor demoed this one time, the bike without ABS stopped a lot sooner in an emergency brake situation than the ABS one. (dry, warm conditions though)

Edit: All images SFW.

Bikes are a different scenario. If you skid in a car and have your wits about you, you can release the breaks, steer into the direction of travel, and regain control. If you skid on a bike, best case is you "low side" (http://www.360stopni.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/Rossi-lo...) and follow the bike on its direction of travel along the floor into whatever is in your path. Or you "high side" (https://i.ytimg.com/vi/0jU-iu7-TAY/hqdefault.jpg) and flip over the bike, hit the floor in front of it (relatively), and the bike follows you into whatever is in your path, and likely hits you when you come to a stop against whatever blocks your path.

As such, bike ABS errs on the side of caution and is much less aggressive than the four-wheel counterpart. Remaining upright and stopping more slowly is a lot safer than risking an off and letting physics, and roadside furniture, decide your fate.

This is also why you always, always wear safety gear on a motorcycle. If you've got good leather and a helmet, a "low side" skid can end up as merely a lot of bruises and stiffness (as I experienced myself once at 35mph). Without proper gear, though, it's guaranteed that you're in for a bad time.

Yes, it is recommended. ABS pumps much faster and with more control than most, if not all drivers. Modern cars also re-balance braking between front/rear and left/right.

Anti-lock brakes are forbidden in Formula 1 in order to make it harder for the drivers. If ABS were reducing how fast a car could decelerate, that regulation wouldn't exist!

ABS can perform worse on loose surfaces like gravel or deep snow, where best braking is provided by locking the wheels. However, steering control on those surfaces while braking is better with ABS.

>Anti-lock brakes are forbidden in Formula 1 in order to make it harder for the drivers

That's actually not a 100% true. Professional drivers don't pump, they attempt to brake just at the threshold of locking in order to get the most out of their available traction. It's a fairly difficult technique that is dependent on experience more than anything, so for the average trackday racer ABS is fine enough.

Yes you should just slam the brakes. ABS is your best chance to get the minimum breaking distance. And you maintain control over the car.

Even without ABS, I have been trained to slam the brakes in emergencies. Without slamming you would lose too much precious stopping distance that you can’t get back.

If you spike the brakes at the wrong time on snow/ice, you will lose control of your vehicle and end up in a far worse situation than if you manually brake.

Please can you explain what you mean by manually braking? At its core, ABS releases the brakes for a wheel when it detects that wheel skidding. Braking is still manual until the locking point. Having ABS enables a driver to slam the brakes and know that won't result in a skid, where a vehicle without ABS may lock the wheels and skid.

The effect when ABS kicks in when braking on snow or ice is for the wheels to maintain slightly (or more) better traction. Sometimes this is undesirable - you'll brake in a shorter distance on loose snow if you lock the wheels - but you generally keep better steering control.

Played around with Vehicle stability Assist + ABS and it takes a lot to lose control of your vehicle. Hard breaking without a hard turn is not going to do it without lot's of ice and a curved road surface.

If you are lucky (or skilled) enough to max out your traction, and if you do not need to steer while braking, I’ve found avoiding the ABS will get you stopped much faster.

The ABS pulsing is designed to allow steering input while braking, which obviously means you are not devoting 100% of your traction to stopping.

A properly functioning ABS should be virtually impossible to beat with a single brake pedal, since it is modulating each wheel independently.

But that doesn’t stop me from being paranoid of “ABS drift” where modulating kicks in so hard that the car just seems to keep coasting forward on and on... you sit there with your foot hard on the pedal wondering if the firmware is just confused.

How often are you engaging emergency braking? The last time I remember activating ABS was on a dry highway onramp due to a lapse in attention while in a fairly old commodity car, and yet despite going faster than I should have been going, the car stopped in an ASTONISHINGLY short distance.

You should slam the brakes and let the ABS take over.

In fact, modern cars with stability control packages do it for you, it is call emergency brake assist. They detect that you engaged in an emergency braking and immediately apply full power with ABS. It means that your instincts are wrong, that most drivers are like you, and that car manufacturers found that the safest thing to do is to override your instincts.

I would say no as ABS tends to let the tires slip a bit before engaging.

Not to forget the one fairly common circumstance where ABS hinders - packed snow and ice where you do need to think about it. ABS can significantly increase your stopping distance.

This is absolutely correct. If you are driving on a loose service (not just _packed_ snow) like snow or gravel, emergency braking is faster without ABS because skidding the wheels causes the material to bunch up in front of the wheels, dramatically reducing vehicle speed.

On a constantly slippery surface (ice, snow, not normally gravel) you may want to disable ABS because the ECU cannot correctly tell the vehicle speed, so may activate ABS incorrectly. However, modern systems to tend to be quite good. I believe it is best to keep systems such as traction control on though.

I learned to drive in Colorado (plenty of snow and ice in the winter), where I was a poor college student driving a typical poor college student car (old, beat-up, no modern safety features like ABS, etc).

Now that I can afford to drive a reasonably modern/safe car and live in Florida, I still can't bring myself to not instinctively pump the brakes when making an emergency stop.

One should simply be driving slower (or preferably not at all) in situations where ice may be a factor; ABS-equipped or not.

A common belief is that ABS always makes braking better. That ignores the situations where it can make things worse and you should probably turn it off.

It's not simply a question of excess speed. One very common situation is where housing estate minor roads have ice or snow, but other routes are cleared or gritted. Most would probably drive in that. ABS can leave you with nearly no braking and in a far worse position than if you'd just turned it off. You might be moving at 10mph or less but slowly sail, with no control, from the minor road into a major road at a junction, or into parked cars.

If it's sheet ice everywhere stay home. :)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com