This is surprising if true. Surely any of these companies would realize that the reputational risk of signing up for such a scheme is much larger than the relatively minuscule benefits it might offer. I would like to see some evidence.
Not necessarily: many people kind of assume the worst anyways, but without getting terribly riled up about it. To them, confirmation will read like tautology, hardly newsworthy. Those same people will tend to be sceptical of puff pieces, but if they occasionally let their guard down the positives might outweigh the negatives even if the conspiracy does come to light.
Google's been paying off academics to make fake academic studies for years. Nobody seems to bat an eye about it anymore, so presumably, these companies have realized that paying people to pretend they have independent opinions about you doesn't actually hurt your reputation much.
> Google's been paying off academics to make fake academic studies for years.