For simple PagerDuty alerts I already need 15 minutes to open the app / logs and figure out what's going on.
Good point, although the way it's described it sounds like the problem cropped up right after deploy. So they would have been watching it actively. But as said above, 17 minutes to notice, figure out what's going on, decide what to do, and propagate the resolution seems reasonable.
Not to mention selectively purging all of the rules created (I assume) at every edge server in their network that were blackholing all of the traffic to the resolver. There's probably a command for it, but all in all 17 minutes seems quite a respectable turnaround time.
Did they really deploy to all 150 DCs at once? Why was this release not done in phases? Not even a canary?
Maybe they did, the strategy is probably to deploy to small DCs first. But that also means the DDOS detection wouldn't trigger. So probably something that didn't get caught during such tests.