Energy Department Proposes Forcing Utilities to Buy Coal Power
popularmechanics.com
popularmechanics.com
Ignoring any of the environmental problems, I'd rather just be taxed if we're going to be giving coal workers welfare.
https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2016/05/06/47...
Welfare for this class wouldn't help me directly but a subsidy for the industry would likely hurt us all in a diffuse fashion over the long-term.
In this case, the administration already attempted the free-market approach (asking FERC to review whether the market rules properly compensated the unique attributes of coal and nuclear). That failed. So now it's big-government central-planning.
On the other hand, there's the "regulate all the things", which is almost always abused by those in power to take advantage of citizens and the environment without any repercussions.
Can we not have a mixture of the two, where there's just enough government involvement to keep us from destroying ourselves and each other, but not too much such that we destroy ourselves and each other?
Back on topic: this instance of government involvement is purely political, at the detriment of the environment and those in it, and should not be legal. I hope this, if it's implemented, is immediately challenged in court.
The commerce clause was obviously never intended to allow the federal government the powers it has today. At least in the case where state A is pointing a gun to your head and sending you to jail for growing medicinal marijuana for only personal use, when your state allows medicinal marijuana anyways, at least you can move with your feet to state B. As it is now this is not possible, because SCOTUS says that this falls under regulating commerce between states, somehow[1].
The only thing which the federal government should be allowed to do here is regulate the pollution externalities and commerce which literally crosses state boundaries.
1) https://www.wnycstudios.org/story/one-nation-under-money/
Whereas the trend into the future is to basically drive coal use down to nothing - it's dirty and harder to deploy then modern alternatives, and even if you kept the mines open the advent of gas turbines means that coal-seam gas would be the fossil fuel you'd be targeting.
A regulation more along those lines would, indeed, seem like a smart move (if it's not already done).
However, there are many thousands of power plants on each of the three US grids (Eastern, Western, Texas (ERCOT). And many different points of failure. [1] How much more should consumers pay for a regulation to keep fuel onsite to mitigate a risk that has, effectively, never happened? [2]
[1] http://fortune.com/2018/01/04/bomb-cyclone-grayson-power-out... [2] https://www.dallasnews.com/news/texas/2011/02/06/freeze-knoc...