I don't see how the situation is actually different now: if you run the official Facebook app on your Galaxh phone then Samsung could scrape and exfiltrate the data anytime it wants. It is Samsung's fault if they do it not Facebook's.
I don't see how the situation is actually different now: if you run the official Facebook app on your Galaxh phone then Samsung could scrape and exfiltrate the data anytime it wants. It is Samsung's fault if they do it not Facebook's.
> Facebook’s view that the device makers are not outsiders lets the partners go even further, The Times found: They can obtain data about a user’s Facebook friends, even those who have denied Facebook permission to share information with any third parties.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/06/03/technology/fa...
> Contrary to claims by the New York Times, friends’ information, like photos, was only accessible on devices when people made a decision to share their information with those friends.
Maybe the confusion is that FB isn't treating these integrations as "third parties" since they're supposed to be pseudo-official FB apps?
Edit: Thinking about it further, this is the crux of the matter, isn't it? Whether or not an FB-approved "mobile experience" counts as an official FB app or a third-party app?
If your phone saved it or your provider saved the data in a server somewhere without your permission and used it for other purposes, that's a pretty big deal. As it is, this should only be a shock if you have no idea how the modern internet works.
The only difference is that the app on the phone has been coded by Blackberry, and the JavaScript code in my browser has been coded by Facebook, except of course for the banner part that my ISP injected, or all the JavaScript code that third parties injected, and who are thus functionally equivalent to the code written by Blackberry.
In this scenario, no third party had access to anyones data, right?
I don’t really care; if you install the facebook app you deserve whatever it does.
Facebook officially blessed other platforms, allowed them to say you were signing into Facebook, and then allowed those platforms to have access not only to your data, but your friends exhaustive data. Facebook was aware of this, explicitly allowed this, and their only safeguard was vaguely worded policies with their partners.
Even if the partners haven't stolen any data or broken their policies, Facebook intentionally and knowingly gave my data to a third party without my consent. Presumably now all 66 of these device partners have my full data, and I did not sign in on their device or otherwise authorize it.
Only for purposes of allowing the user to interact with Facebook. The platforms themselves couldn’t use the data for anything other than supporting user actions.
This is perfectly reasonable and is why APIs exist.
The issue, which has not been repeated, would be if those platforms retained data without user consent and used the data for other purposes. That would violate the contract they signed with Facebook and be bad for use privacy.
To a non technology person, these two very different things sound similar (Facebook let Microsoft access use data). But this is meaningless without more context.
Is there any evidence that the API was actually used to arbitrarily request and exfiltrate other users profiles? If not, this is strictly only "Facebook allowed other developers to write Facebook apps": there is no way that could possible work without offering an API with this level off access to the app.
I friended my cousin because she is my cousin. I didn't think about what kind of device she uses. I certainly didn't intend for her to hand my personal information over to a company that I don't know.