http://foreignpolicy.com/2011/01/18/seymour-hersh-unleashed/
Thanks, truly, for letting me off the hook as "some automatic spy/asset/plant". That definitely doesn't at all come across as the personal attack it clearly, obviously is.
“Many of them are members of Opus Dei,” Hersh continued. “They do see what they’re doing — and this is not an atypical attitude among some military — it’s a crusade, literally. They see themselves as the protectors of the Christians. They’re protecting them from the Muslims [as in] the 13th century. And this is their function.” “They have little insignias, these coins they pass among each other, which are crusader coins,” he continued. “They have insignia that reflect the whole notion that this is a culture war. … Right now, there’s a tremendous, tremendous amount of anti-Muslim feeling in the military community.”
Thats it. Thats all. "Many of them", "not an atypical attitude". Your quote, that started this sub thread was this: "Among them, he believes that USSOCOM is run by a secret cabal of Opus Dei Catholics". Little bit of a difference here. In fact I'll go out on a limb and say a rather large difference. Again, Jeff Sharlet, Mike Weinstein, there are a number of others who have done the serious, necessary investigative reporting on this and if anything its even more frightening then the comments from the Doha speech Hersh gave (which for the record were also uncontroversial at the time he gave them to anyone who has followed military reporting). I might take a moment to point out I was in ROTC in college, my family has served for generations. You can take my criticism any way you want, but calling out your crit of Hersh, for the sloppiness and exageration it is, is not a personal attack. As for the comment about spy/plant/whatever, I've been on this site long enough to know that was a bit of thing some years back and was trying to go out of my way to note that I don't think that about you, that I think many people make these arguments/judgments from places of sincerity, but that that doesn't make them correct.
EDIT: I'm going to assume that Thomas has no interest in seriously reckoning with what I'm trying to say and simply add, anyone who happens on this comment subthread, take the time to read the unfortunately long LRB piece linked in my original comment, its important. Its kind of amazing (and sad) that this discussion devolved into this back and forth because that piece, the response to that piece in the American press (by people exactly Blake Hounshell btw) and the subsequent way things worked out in regard to Mike Flynn, Trump, Obama, the election, and the now Russia Investigation could all themselves be wrapped up into their own long form piece on political and media culture and the consequences of dismissing people like Hersh. Here it is again for the interested: https://www.lrb.co.uk/v38/n01/seymour-m-hersh/military-to-mi...
Thank you for acknowledging that first-hand sources for this actually exist, and aren't "egregious nonsense" that were "off the cuff remarks in a foreign country that were not recorded and have been reported on second and third hand".
Perhaps you and I have reached the limit of how much we can productively discuss this particular topic, now.
The remark about "second and third hand" was a point about their being, to my knowledge, no transcripts or video, it was poorly phrased.
Finally maybe leave off the pseudo-moral posturing about being "attacked", given I went out of my way to qualify what I said, and, in a subsequent comment, clarified the "spy" remark and did so precisely because thats charge is a serious one and I had seen you be smeared with it, thanks for literally attacking me.
http://foreignpolicy.com/2011/01/22/transcript-the-obamabush...
tptacek's summary is accurate; Hersh did not just claim that "many" people in the military were in this cabal, Hersh claimed that "a large percentage" of JSOC and SOCOM were involved or supported this religious cabal, including Admiral McRaven, who commanded SOCCOM from 2011 to 2014.
> That’s an attitude that pervades, I’m here to say, a large percentage of the Special Operations Command, the Joint Special Operations Command and Stanley McChrystal, the one who got in trouble because of the article in Rolling Stone, and his follow-on, a Navy admiral named McRaven, Bill McRaven — all are members or at least supporters of Knights of Malta. McRaven attended, so I understand, the recent annual convention of the Knights of Malta they had in Cyprus a few months back in November. They’re all believers — many of them are members of Opus Dei.
Not once has Thomas or now you, addressed this. Jeremy Scahill has covered this in both reported pieces, interviews and at least one book.
Here's some more:
https://www.advocate.com/commentary/2018/3/29/christian-take...
https://www.economist.com/erasmus/2014/09/09/one-army-under-...
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/08...
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/uploads/attachments/For_God_...
I could go on, citing any number of people from all across the political spectrum.
And for the record, no, I think tptaceks summary was not accurate, either in content or in context. Freely throwing around that Hersh thinks the specops brass is run by a cabal is not the same as what he actually said, none, I repeat none of which was actually a reported piece he himself had published. It was a throw away comment in a speech. Full stop. Which, again, is outside of internet slap fights and access journalism types like Blake Hounshell, utterly uncontroversial. I could post links like the above literally all night and not reach the bottom of reporting on the slowly theocratiztion of the upper reaches of the American military.http://nymag.com/nymetro/news/people/features/11719/
He's seen (rightly) as an authority, and he's speaking in a venue where the topic is non-fiction. People have a right to question those assertions and ask for evidence, which he is free to provide or to walk back.
How have ya'll spent more than half a dozen comments now with out reckoning with any of the pieces I've linked? Seriously. I've linked a number of pieces now backing up what Hersh has said. Aren't you a journalist? Even a professor of journalism?
Second, you're sugarcoating Hersh's argument about JSOC/USSOCOM. If all Hersh had said was that there were an unusual and disquieting number of fundamentalist Christians in the high ranks of SOCOM, few people would bat an eyelash. But he didn't say that. He said that USSOCOM was run by a secret conspiracy of Opus Dei and the Knights of Malta. He is, if not 100%, then at least 96.3% into Umberto Eco territory here.
Check back in another 5-10 years (maybe after his Cheney book is published?) and we'll see if he hasn't made it all the way to 23 Skidoo.
The mainstream press beyond Hersh has reported on Christian fundamentalism at leadership levels at the USAFA during Bush's presidency. Also former undersecretary of Defense for Intelligence General Boykin's actions and statements.
There are also stories Bush told Chirac about Gig and Magog, and biblical prophecy during the war in Iraq. How true that is I do not know.
I see this type of talk on cable TV late at night where I live. I can imagine what radio and TV in Oklahoma or Mississippi is playing. I am not surprised this has gotten into the water. Nor do I find it odd Hersh would mention this in an interview or speech, it must seem strange to a rational secular person like himself.
The military fundamentalist news was not Hersh specific and was reported more widely.
(The funny thing is, I think he's talking about challenge coins --- that is, I think he's another civilian confronted by the lunacy that is challenge coin culture and believing that it must be some crazy thing that just a few people in the government are doing because they're out of their skulls, and not a weird thing that everyone in the federal government does because they are all collectively out of their skulls. You saw the same thing with claims about Trump minting his own special currency --- and Obama before that.)
You didn't?
>"Among them, he believes that USSOCOM is run by a secret cabal of Opus Dei Catholics"
I'm not sure what you're arguing here. You're accusing me that I'm overselling what Hersh said. And then you basically say, well, other people have reported this stuff too.
Post links to what you say. And frankly I don't care about various reports "about leadership levels at the USAFA". I'm not arguing whether or not there are fundamentalists in the military. The original discussion were assertions that Hersh made that have been questioned. Hersh made assertions about two people specifically -- McChrystal and McRaven, of being secret members/supporters of religious groups. AFAIK, he still may be right, even though McChrystal, at least, has outright denied it:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/01...
Also General Boykin is listed as the Grand Chancellor of the Knights of Malta on their web page ( http://www.theknightshospitallers.org/grand-chancellor.html ). The old crusader order. Boykin gave a speech in a church in October 2003 that seemed to cast the war as a holy war between Christianity and Islam.
This sentiment exists for some in the military and Hersh mentions it in speeches and interviews.