Hacker News Reader

Comment by stcredzero | Hacker News Reader

Then how about making earpods/headsets that don't suck and fall apart? (To be fair, I've heard that the Apple in-ear ones are decent, at least to start.)

View on HN

Apple's in-ear phones are indeed vastly better than the default earbuds -- in fact, they compare favourably with similarly-priced offerings from Shure and Etymotic, and are competitive on price.

I suspect Apple's standard "free" earbuds are actually deliberately bad because they're intended to upsell the customer on a better pair of earphones -- and a customer who's buying in an Apple store will of course be exposed to Apple's in-ear phones as a possible upgrade.

(Full disclosure: I use a pair of Ultimate Ears TripleFi 10's which kick the shit out of the Apple ear canal phones ... on the other hand, they're a lot more expensive. In the sub-$100 earphone range, the Apple in-ear phones are fine.)

I have a pair of Etymotic ER4P's. http://www.etymotic.com/ephp/er4.aspx

They are truly reference-class equipment. (My Brain-Age2 word-discrimination score would jump a whopping amount just by using those!) I don't use them unless I'm on a plane, though. In-ear is just too much effort/overhead for me.

These Sennheisers had decent sound and folded up to fit in a dandy little case. However, my girlfriend at the time told me that they look so dorky, she didn't want to be seen in public with me wearing them. http://amzn.com/B001NZ8PHQ

Then I told her that there's even better sounding headphones (non-iPhone) in the same price range that look even dorkier. She didn't believe me until I sent her the link. http://amzn.com/B00001P4ZH

Apple needs to solve the headphone/headset design problem!

That last one does deserve a 'wow'. There's just something about them that makes me say 'no'.

Grados, on the other hand, are full of gooey retro goodness: http://www.gradolabs.com/product_pages/rs1.htm I have an 80, and it's amazing how many random music geeks will start talking to you just because you have them on.

Since you've used some: have a recommended starting point for Etymotics? I've been looking for something isolating to complement the I-can-hear-that-ant-tapdancing-through-my-music of the Grados.

A coworker of mine had the made-for-iPod Etymotics. (6i) The build quality wasn't even half as good as my ER4's. The ER4's are really robust. I can't imagine them wearing out, ever! The 6i's are an old model, though. I don't know what the newer ones are like.

I bought my sister some bluetooth Etymotics which are no longer made. She really liked those. I also have an Ety.com headset, which is really good at what it does. (Allows you to have a phone conversation in really noisy environments.)

My advice: try some from a store with a really good return policy. They are not for everyone. Also, I'd just buy the ER4's, unless you want an iPhone headset. They are a very good in-ear phone with superb isolation, especially if you are sitting still, and you can use them to do serious sound work.

I've bought mine from http://www.headphone.com/. (Not affiliated with them in any way.)

Another question then, if you don't mind:

I (apparently) have rather large ear canals, and a lot of in-ears don't seal properly. I've had the worst luck with the triple-flange style. As such, I kind of need something with larger sizes than normal, and / or get something custom molded (which I'm seriously considering). Know a good place to look for any of that?

Etymotic has a custom in-ear mold voucher program, which costs $100. You can also look up the Make DIY instructions, which uses a $12 kit.

http://makeprojects.com/Project/Custom-Fit-Earbuds/199/1

I do not recommend the Apple in-ear ones. I got a pair of $15 in-ear headphones that sound much, much beter (compared to the $70 for the Apple set). The Apple pair sounded tinny, which for the price really isn't worth it.

Now to find ones that sound good but have a mic+remote...

edit: them cheap earbuds that sounded better IMO - http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000I68BD4/

The main problem with the Apple in ears buds is the seal. Fix the seal with some decent buds like http://www.complyfoam.com/Product/T%7B48%7D400 and the bass comes. Its nearly as good as my westone UM2's that I have. All it took was some cheap foam

Great tip. Unfortunately I lost the Apple earbuds on a trip to Seattle last month.

I just assumed that the rubber was supposed to come off after about a month of use, since it happens so regularly.

The in-ear phones have great sound, but they fall apart after about six months unless you're super OCD about wrapping them up in the case every time.

My brother in law works at apple, he says that the in_ear headsets are terrible plus twice the cost...

They sound better than the cheap $15 earphones Sony or Philips wills sell you. They are much better than pretty much anything that comes with any other device.

They still suck. But they suck less than the competition.

Agreed, in terms of Audio quality, the Apple headphones are their worst product.

In terms of Audio quality, the Apple mouse is even worse.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com