I can absolutely see how a windowless plane could make someone feel claustrophobic.
Equally, even though I fly every few months (so you’d think I’d be used to it by now) I actually don’t like being reminded that I’m 38,000ft in the air. It freaks me out. I like it when I can’t see outside the window into the clouds. (However, I do kinda like seeing out the window while landing, but that’s only a tiny fraction of the overall flight.)