For support-related tasks, find someone that will do the support for a percentage of the new revenue you realize with some version of the suggestion below.
Tell all your existing, un-paying customers that in 30 days, you're going to start charging $19.99/month for it, but if they sign up before the pricing starts, they're in for $9.99 (or $12.99--whatever floats your boat). Leave all your existing customers happy by not charging them more.
You could also consider an annual subscription model where they pay either $240 a whole year, or $199 if they sign up before the date of the price change.
A lot of your customers will say no and leave, but some will likely say yes and contribute to your top-line. Either way, you'll make more money than you're making now. Be sure to explain why you're charging: E.g.: I think the service is valuable and in order to keep it running, I need to charge something for it.
THEN, once you have more paying customers, you can either sell the app and charge more for it or sit back and have a pssive revenue stream.
UPDATE: @ barmstrong, If you're not interested in the above and decide you DO want to sell it, contact me and we can talk about me buying it from you.