You can also just squat on one. As long as you avoid using the trademarks ("usb" and the logo) there is nothing that can be done to you even in the US. This is basically what most Chinese products do.
Yeah... please don't do this. There exist better options than polluting a shared namespace. It's just like putting your private network in IP space you don't own.
Not at all. Because it does not cost you $5,000 to get an IP address.
Yes, yes it can. It's 5k for a Vendor ID. That's like a /16 subnet allocation in IPv4, which could easily cost far more than than a Vendor ID.
Yes but most people don't need an entire Vendor ID, but that's the minimum you can buy. They even banned vendors from selling individual product IDs.
USB IF are dicks.
Even a relatively small subnet (/22 - 1024 IPs) will cost you $1-2000/year under most NICs.
What is the advantage of applying for one as a FOSS project as opposed to squatting?
Well-behaved devices won't step on allocated IDs, so you can safely associate your device ID with your corresponding driver.
You will get your product name visible in lsusb that way.
Not everybody wants to open source and give away for free everything they do, nor pay $5,000 to license something that is actually just a number. This is especially true for USB devices that follow the hid spec. They don't need drivers, so even if you happen to have one associated with that vendor ID and product id, the OS will not load it.
I have seen devices that used 0000 as VID/PID. It generally worked, but some software don't like this. (eg. virtualbox usb passthrough)
It is how Chinese you can get 100 Chinese wireless devices all with one MAC
MAC is different because you need one by device, so having to buy them in "bulk" is a lot more reasonable. USBIDs ought to be purchasable individually (or large enough that you wouldn't have to purchase them).
Yeah, if they were focused on what is best for users then at some point they would have added the option to use a UUID.