I love zen koans, especially hacker koans,
This is a validation of his authority.
Stop acting like he's some kind of sacred lamb and go look at the actual work he's produced other than being a 'personality'.
I thought Hackerne.ws would be more circumspect about this.
However, as ESR himself writes: http://catb.org/jargon/html/meaning-of-hack.html
> Hacking might be characterized as 'an appropriate application of ingenuity'. Whether the result is a quick-and-dirty patchwork job or a carefully crafted work of art, you have to admire the cleverness that went into it. An important secondary meaning of hack is 'a creative practical joke'. This kind of hack is easier to explain to non-hackers than the programming kind. Of course, some hacks have both natures.
If this is how ESR defines "hacking", then his claim to be a hacker is not, also, an implicit claim that he is a good programmer (that one must then refute.) He simply claims to "apply ingenuity" and "joke around"—which, it's pretty clear from the OP link, he does, in the medium of prose.
Not a certain kind of programming. Just programming in general. I think in most people's minds, the concept "hacker" implicitly includes the concept "programmer."
ESR claims that these koans appeal to hackers. You like them, and you're a hacker, so unless he got lucky, he has at least some small insight into what makes hackers tick.
He managed to be on the ground at the right time for the whole free software and hacker culture thing, but as far as actual coding goes, he's nothing special.
Well, haters gotcha hate, especially when there is a guru.
I'm having trouble understanding your comments here as anything other than defensiveness or elitism.
This community is starting to feel more like slashdot and TechCrunch collaborated on a sister site than a bastion of valuable conversation.
The problem is that Eric stomps around claiming things that aren't his. He claims to be a "core Linux developer", when in reality, the only code he has is the kernel are the speaker driver (since pushed out) and some minor use of ncurses used for vt100 emulation in thr console driver.
Eric may be boastful and loud, but he can't code.
ESR can't sling enough code to contribute to a random OSS project without people getting exasperated, of late.
Don't spout platitudes at people you don't know.