Someone however, does not.
https://scottlocklin.wordpress.com/2010/08/24/nano-nonsense-...
Do you really think that this is novel in any way whatsoever? There is some yearly chance of nuclear war, and I don't know about geopolitics so I have a prior distribution over that yearly chance. Should I cite this paper?
I actually really like the authors, and for all I know the paper may have some new insights or perform a calculation that hasn't been done before, but let's not pretend that prior distributions over probabilities is a new idea.
Is Fermi is some well established science, with repeated experimental proof, upon which numerous other conjectures have been built on?
Does it really require a novel approach to attack its basis?
> Everyone considered this option. From the very first day the paradox was posed. We don't know the parameters well, it's within our margin of error that no one else is out there, so it's an option.
And the person I replied to was rebutting this point (that the approach is obvious and considered long ago).
It's fine to write review articles, or clean up old arguments and repackage them, but it shouldn't be presented as a new idea, and in particular it should point to the prior work.