1. Monopolization has increased in markets in general (see: ATT-Time Warner merger).
2. ISPs have realized what they can do with their increased monopolies, and have started developing technical strategies for doing so.
3. Regardless of this, these companies are getting certain things from the public, such as right-of-way. They act like they owe nothing to the public, which is a lie.
It's a logical mistake to assume that behavior of ISPs in the past is what they will do in the future.
I'll start respecting the arguments against net neutrality when:
1. Private citizens and government entities are allowed to charge arbitrary rates for ISP lines to go over their property.
2. ISPs are legally responsible for the content of any and all packets going over their infrastructure.
3. All legal challenges / obstacles to public / municipal ISPs are dropped and eliminated.