Hacker News Reader

Comment by sonnyblarney | Hacker News Reader

Consumer culture was created really at the dawn of the 20th century. The elites realized that in order to keep 'growth' going they had to get people to continuously 'buy stuff'. Hence consumer culture has been systematically promoted since then.

I once visited a friend in London, his family had a really nice property, worth millions for sure. And then in this kitchen some really funny ancient oven and toaster stuff. It still worked fine. So why replace it? North Americans just keeping buying new, we're the epiphany of that culture.

But at some point in your career you might connect the dots and realize you need people to 'buy buy buy' in order for your sales to remain healthy and for you to keep your job so you can support your family etc. etc..

It's a weird vicious/virtuous circle and I don't thin UBI etc. will solve it. There are innumerable actual innovations and advancements that come out of the rat race :).

View on HN

> Consumer culture was created really at the dawn of the 20th century. The elites realized that in order to keep 'growth' going they had to get people to continuously 'buy stuff'

This reverses cause and effect. For most of human history, real productive capacity didn't change from generation to generation. Elites fought to sit on more stuff; there was no point bringing peasants into the mix.

The industrial revolution (and the Black Plague, in Europe) changed that dynamic. Real economic growth became a thing. And workers needed to be competed for. That gave them bargaining power in the economy, which they converted into re-tooling it away from solely making toys for the elites and towards producing goods and services for the masses.

It's always comforting to imagine some disembodied "elites" calling the shots and making a plan. In reality, our systems are more chaotic.

> And then in this kitchen some really funny ancient oven and toaster stuff.

Sounds like an AGA [1], they are still a consumer culture signal even if they don't look it to an outsider.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AGA_cooker

If so, the parent post couldn't have chosen a more ironic example. AGA cookers are a ridiculous Veblen good, regardless of age.

If the AGA is new (within the last decade or two), those people spent tens of thousands of dollars on a freaking oven. That's more than most people would spend on an entire kitchen remodel.

If the AGA is not new (from before 1990 or so), it's horrendously energy inefficient. A modern sub-$1,000 oven would pay for itself in energy savings in no time.

> we're the epiphany of that culture

*epitome

Or, if you want to use hyperbole, we're the apotheosis of that culture--in the "exalted or glorified example" sense.

Note that what I mean is that it is not just to buy stuff, but also to extract as much profit as possible. And commodities where that isn't possible tends to be outsourced to other countries like China, making our trade deficit worse.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com