All caches have equal hit rates in the limit when the size of the cache approaches infinity. For finite caches, ARC often wins. In practical experience I've found that a weighted ARC dramatically outperformed LRU for DNS RR caching, in terms of both hit rate and raw CPU time spent per access. This is because it was easy to code an ARC cache that had lock-free access to frequently referenced items; once an item had been promoted to T2 no locks were needed for most accesses. With LRU it's necessary to have exclusive access to the entire cache in order to evict something and add something else.
Of course there are more schemes than just LRU and ARC, and one can try to employ lock-free schemes more than I'm willing to do. This is just my experience.