"In the recruiting work I have done I've asked thousands of programmers to explain the concept behind design patterns"
I'd have to find some data to back up what I suspect, which is that the bottom X% of programmers (or at least would-be programmers) cycle through all those job interviews where this lack of knowledge becomes apparent (unless you're recruiting for a really high-level position where the top programmers might be interested in applying, and even then many are already content where they are).
So, if you're any good, you're not as likely to be interviewed, and so the population is flawed.
That doesn't mean that design patterns have or have not flopped. At least, every one of my coworkers have been taught the patterns. Whether we apply them or not might merit a study, one with a methodology that doesn't mislead the observer and where a more valid conclusion might be reached (it could even be the same conclusion, that is, that they have flopped).