UI/UX tricks against GDPR and users
medium.com
medium.com
But there is another pattern, that actually is allowed. Have everything deselected, put a "select all" button somewhere people easily click it by mistake, and offer no "deselect all" button.
Its up to the EU authorities to rule on this tho.
“Sounds Good, Thanks” doesn't seem like informed consent to me, so it doesn't grant the site owner any extra permission.
https://twitter.com/Martin_Adams/status/1006439897270546434
Only until now, I notice the optional actually says 'Accept all and continue'. I fell for it. It's relying on people's habit of not expecting a confirmation button to change the state of the options.
With that said, obviously clicking 300+ checkboxes instead of having an "uncheck all" is absurd. But, I can see how a site that has been around for years could have 300+. I just cleaned up a website the other day that had 50 (we pruned it down to 20 after 30 of them couldn't give us info on their GDPR policy).
I'm also concerned about the blanket statement that companies that say they care about your privacy don't. I've told people I care about their privacy and I actually mean it... :(
This kind of behavior may be going against the spirit of the GDPR, which states consent must be "freely given". Presenting hundreds of check boxes to click may be considered coercing the user into consenting. Will be interesting to see the first rulings about these kinds of popups and the even riskier "consent-walls".
Probably I'm just picking a nit here, but since is the crux of the last paragraph, I'm taking it as thesis, and as a thesis, it seems overblown... unless there are really no companies out there who care about your privacy.
Undoubtedly, there are companies who will choose to say "We care about your privacy" when they don't really mean it, but I think the assertion that no company does needs more evidence than this single data point.
You know what's great about the GDPR? It's that all this is stripped naked and lies just in front of our eyes. The requirement to click hundreds of buttons in order not to be tracked is a slap in the face of each European user.
Honestly, I'd be surprised if InfoWorld even intended this behavior, while it seems just as likely that some requirements got lost in the shuffle of trying to hurriedly get GDPR compliance on the page.
Considering how few people still understand what GDPR actually does and doesn't allow, it's not really shocking to me that their attempt at compliance was done so ham-handedly, or that it might even have made them less compliant than they were before.
… I’d add “never trust their information” - in the case of InfoWorld, their written articles. If a site is willing to manipulate readers to obtain consent, there’s no reason to think that its sponsorship disclosure policy or even its writing wouldn’t reflect the same priorities.
And then, when it's finally unblocked, you get this:
"Thank you for sharing your preferences with us. We are in the process of preparing the site to accommodate your privacy preferences and appreciate your patience as we do so during this temporary period. Please check back soon. In the meantime, if you would like to change your preferences, click below."
Screw you, forbes.com. Before they had a thing which blocked adblockers. Of if you disabled the adblocker you'd still have to wait about 10 seconds for an interstitial page to show you ads. I just wish I could remove you from my Google searches forever (as in, I wouldn't have to filter it out all the time).
Mind you, not sure how much of the modern web would work once you disable JS and cookies, so I guess you might as well close the browser and go outside.