- Such vehicles would not be street legal.
- They would not be safe for passengers.
- They would be unable to carry the necessary payloads.
- Most of the weight of a car is in the chassis anyway, not the body.
Edit: at any rate, Google did do something like what you described at an earlier stage of testing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HJnjuhBIhwc They seem to be past that point, though.I would think another big reason though is that the handling and response of such a car would be very different from a real car. Stopping distances, acceleration, cornering, wind behavior, would all be different.
It seems to me the real problem would be that A: You need the car to be on the real streets, so at a minimum, it must be street legal. B: You need it to be on all the streets, including highways and such, so we're at least up to a Smart car level of body. From there it really isn't that great a leap to a full sedan chassis. Would one of those little cars even have room for all the requisite sensors? Even if they did, sedans are just so much more useful.
So it seems like the minimum practical car to test with is a sedan, and that's enough to kill people. Even the little Smart cars are plenty enough to kill people.
On slow roads, I've often seen them driven around summer communities. It would be silly for the government to not allow this.
> They would not be safe for passengers.
The above commenter pointed out "enough trust for 2 tons of metal and a passenger," so I'm assuming the idea is that they don't have a passenger in them at this stage. Additionally, regardless of whether an SUV is safer for the individual behind the wheel, shouldn't it be that individual accepting the risk and not a random pedestrian who didn't consent to this experiment?
> They would be unable to carry the necessary payloads.
Do they really carry payloads at this stage? Isn't the focus on building a safe autonomous system?
> Most of the weight of a car is in the chassis anyway, not the body.
The golf carts are 1/8th to 1/4th the weight of a crossover, for example.
The substantial issue I'd guess would be the differences in all aspects of performance between a real car and a golf cart, but at this stage companies like Uber should clearly just be testing detection of pedestrians et al.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HJnjuhBIhwc
That stage of testing is past, though.
It seems reasonable that there should be some regulation on "x miles per incident" before autonomous vehicle companies are allowed to move forward from carts to full-sized cars.
Based on the stats that have been posted on HN, Google is very safe. Uber, on the other hand, is not.
- For the perceived feeling of safety in larger cars.
- For the off chance that once a year they might need to take some extra large load (e.g. help a friend with moving).
AKA. emotional needs, not practical ones.
Carpooling is not a meaningful comparison. Carpooling requires picking up (and tolerating) other people on a semi-rigid schedule. Hailing a self-driving car has all the benefits of driving solo, plus you don't have to drive.
I get that SUV's aren't for everyone. Acting like they are for no one is silly though.
Though to be honest, me & my SO are driving a compact MPV which is larger than our basic needs (no children so far) - we were wondering whether to get something smaller, but it was the best used vehicle available within the budget at the time. And we frequently find use for the extra interior space.
I grew up where it snowed a lot. I've never owned anything that sat particularly high nor with 4WD, and I've never missed a day of work due to snow.
My street floods.
If the water is above the air intake of a Honda Civic, your SUV isn't going to do you any good.
I frequently want to carry a large number of items.
I'm continually shocked at how few SUVs exceed the cargo volume of our 35mpg Scion xB. I've moved furniture for a friend because his Equinox wouldn't carry it. I rented a Nissan Xterra to carry a bicycle box that fit less snugly in the Scion than it did in the Nissan. SUVs might have a use, but carrying things is not one of them.
Until you threw in the ol' "I have a family" (because the children can not be seen in a Volvo wagon), I thought you were doing a parody of "Excuses SUV Owners Use to Justify Their Big-Ass Vehicle". I'm pretty sure I was wrong.
That's like saying you don't need a fullsize truck because the methheads seem to do just find hauling scrap metal in their Dodge Caravan.
For a load with a constant amount of space usage (e.g. kids + sports stuff) having more space will make hauling that load less of a chore. If you do it regularly then the luxury of a bigger vehicle is often considered worth the cost.
I can and have hauled fridges, office desks, etc on the roof of my wagon. I always prefer to use my truck for those things unless the item can't stand getting dirty from the truck or I'm going so far that the extra fuel economy and better driving experience of the car makes it worth it. Strapping a desk to the roof of a car and not doing a crap job is a chore. Just tossing it in a truck and strapping it down takes like 30sec.
A vehicle with more space can haul more crap or haul the same crap more easily.
As an aside, I wouldn't let my kids be seen in a Volvo Wagon. I'm white trash, not some hipster. A rusted out Subaru is more my style.
That's like saying that one kinda, umm, perhaps didn't completely comprehend my point. Unless you're arguing that a Dodge Caravan has more space than a Ford F-150 (and maybe it does, dunno).
having more space will make hauling that load less of a chore.
Yes, I completely agree, that's why I like the Scion over an SUV.
As an aside, I wouldn't let my kids be seen in a Volvo Wagon.
So you're worried about the image you project as well. Fair enough, I think that might apply to many vehicle owners including, to a degree larger than I care to admit, myself.
The classic SUV, in other words a truck chassis, is an ever shrinking part of the market. FJ Cruiser, Xterra, 4Runner...
Also, both the FJ Cruiser and Xterra have been discontinued, which further emphasizes that "traditional" SUVs hardly exist these days.
But my overall point is that I believe for most people (myself included), choice of a car is atypical in a way in which it includes emotions instead of pragmatism.
This sounds like something a caucasian single person would say.
Anyone with small kids would immediately have to think about the logistics of child car seats plus a stroller/wagon (at a minimum), plus whatever else would be appropriate to bring to the target destination (e.g. chairs and a cooler box for a picnic). Those are certainly not thing people do in an off-change.
Also don't forget cultures with tight-knit families (e.g. indians) where it's not uncommon for grandparents to live with you (and by extension travel with you) as well.
Anyone with small kids would immediately have to think
about the logistics of child car seats plus a
stroller/wagon [...]
Sure, but you can fit a 4-person family [1] into a Toyota Corolla, even with car seats and a stroller. I've seen it done plenty of times.My theory is the increasing car sizes are driven by increasing waist sizes; a 220 lb couple could be cramped in a car their 140 lb grandparents might have found plenty large enough.
[1] The average family is 3.14 persons in the US in 2017 according to https://www.statista.com/statistics/183657/average-size-of-a...
WTF? White people don't have trucks (or SUVs) and families?
Of course caucasians buy SUVs too...
Source: I drive a small car in Oakland.
I suppose this could be solvable with proper road infrastructure design and actually punishing people for bad parking.
It'd be really nice to have a golf-cart-ish car, a little SmartCar, a proper sportscar, an SUV, and a big pickup truck, and use the appropriate one in each situation.
But, even people that can afford the spare cash for that kind of stable of cars rarely do it -- it's just too inconvenient, too much maintenance (or too big a garage to keep them all in to minimize maintenance), depreciation, insurance, etc. and nevermind the constraints of city or near-city living where space is at a premium.
So, people just get the closest thing that fits most of their use-cases, and that's most often SUVs and crossovers.
I'm and example; while I'd be happiest in a small sportscar and it'd work for 85+% of my trips (and save fuel money), my occasional and unpredictable need to carry big packages for work keeps me using an SUV for my daily driver. Even if I wanted the extra expenses, I have winters and no spare garage. So...
2. I understand that Google does the vast majority of its testing without any iron at all, but rather tests new software using recorded input.
https://www.google.com/search?q=google+self+driving+bubble+c...
But who cares? It still seems like it would be valuable to collect many millions of simulation hours and eventual live testing hours with far safer vehicle types first, at minimum just as a proof of concept and a prove-out of the appropriate testing and evaluation infrastructure (e.g. we’ll probably be a lot better at extending the audit process that evaluates autonomous golf carts into an audit process for common cars than we would be just jumping straight to auditing cars without ever having audited anything else).
In fact, it seems irresponsible to not prove out the entire end to end ecosystem (from simulations to live testing to auditing to a commercially approved deployment in some limited scenario) using a much smaller scale application and vehicle type.
I can understand the arms race motivation for cutting corners and jumping straight to the widest use cases on the part of corporations. But I can’t see why society would want it handled that way.
Because these self driving cars aren't being developed to solve a hypothetical problem, they're being developed to solve the very real and current problem of cars killing 40,000 people in the US each year.
If extra safety measures result in killing ten fewer people in testing, but delay the introduction of self-driving cars by a year or two, that could mean thousands of preventable deaths still occurred. Are the lives of those people definitely getting killed right now worth 100x less than the lives of those who might get killed with these tests?
And this isn't baseless speculation. People are already obviously dying all the time, and improving these cars' software would be much harder without the kind of real-world data they're currently collecting.
Possible, but speculative.
> Also, estimating how safe sekf-driving car is you should take into account all the cases where human took over.
Sure, but on the other hand, the SDC's are continually improving as a group in a way that is not true for humans. This makes it harder to extrapolate into the future one way or the other.
> Also there are many accidents in weather conditions where self driving car would not be able to drive at all.
If you mean environments where humans also can't drive worth a damn, yes, probably true, although SDC's may yet prove better, since that's a technical problem rather than a social understanding one.
But 90%+ of accidents involve human error, so even if you can't completely eliminate deaths, you can still radically reduce them.
Yes, exactly. This is the reason you would want the technology to be developed slowly and carefully, incubated in a safer scenario for a long time to ensure it can be effectively audited and deployed when it comes time to use it for the intended, safety-improving commercial traffic use cases.
What you sounds sounds like good reason to more strongly favor a lengthy test and prove-out cycle on safer and more limited vehicle types, long before testing on commercial traffic vehicles.
The rate of auto-related deaths happening today certainly would not be a reason to hastily rush the technology and jump directly to extensive testing on the final commercial traffic end use cases. Trying to "hurry up" and prevent those deaths could counter-intuitively lead to more deaths because the infrastructure and auditing processes were not proved out and slowly ramped up to real traffic scenarios.
You assert this, but provide no reasoning. I mean, the status quo is "hurrying up", since there are no general standards companies are being held to, and yet only one company has killed anyone, and surprise surprise, it's the company with an extensive history of ethical problems, and they screwed up in a way that's really obvious and foreseeable.
The status quo is a free for all, and yet we don't have much in the way of deaths and injuries from the millions of miles being driven by computers. It seems like companies are already themselves being fairly safe, so how many deaths would you actually be avoiding by implementing more stringent standards right now?
In many industries, from food development to drug development to medical devices to clean energy tech to child car seats to film ratings we have nuanced and highly involved government oversight and regulations to try to ensure levels of safety, ethical and thorough clinical testing, ratings systems that map to outcomes, etc. etc. Yes, of course they are not always perfect, but that is beside the point entirely. The ubiquitous and widespread use of such regulations is a direct statement that companies cannot be trusted, have repeatedly proved through history to be untrustworthy regarding safety over and over across many industries, and that it's a civic need to have independent oversight. We can debate the amounts, regulatory capture, etc., but absolutely could not ever believe something like saying the status quo is just an industry free-for-all.
In fact, cases where start-ups try to skirt these issues in under-regulated industries are extremely rare and do not at all represent any type of status quo in any sense. There is absolutely no sense in which that maps to the way things work. It is rare for a industry to come up with its own testing and evaluation strategy where societal outcomes aren't brought up as first-principle constraints on how the innovation has to proceed.
> "It seems like companies are already themselves being fairly safe, so how many deaths would you actually be avoiding by implementing more stringent standards right now?"
This is just so egregiously unrelated to reality that I do not have the time resources to even start to reply. My mouth is agape that someone would think this.
> "You assert this, but provide no reasoning."
I agree with this for self-driving cars. I am not an expert of self-driving cars, and feel it's perfectly fair for me to say that in virtually every other industry, regulations are needed to ensure corporations don't actively harm people, falsify results, rush to market, etc., and that it logically and obviously extends to self-driving cars without any need for some onerous debate. The idea that companies are just trustworthy to rush this stuff to commercial markets does not need to be taken seriously. It's just obviously not so.
Beyond that, I completely agree I am not the expert on it, and would defer to e.g. the NTSB to decide how companies are behaving with regard to proper testing. The only part I would add is that as a citizen, my strong preference is for the testing to be gradual with a high emphasis on validation and a gradual proof of concept moving from simpler vehicles and situations to more complex ones. Regardless of what the raw machine learning capabilities are in terms of self-driving, this is needed to prove out the evaluation and auditing infrastructure as much as anything else -- essentially to prove that we have a framework for holding the companies accountable in the right ways.
I'm specifically talking about the current development of self-driving cars. I'm not sure why you thought I was generalizing to all activity among all industries.
> This is just so egregiously unrelated to reality that I do not have the time resources to even start to reply. My mouth is agape that someone would think this.
What's weird about it? Again, we're not talking about solving some hypothetical future problem, in which case I would agree with you about being hyper-cautious and safe. Tens of thousands of people die every year right now. Where is your mouth-agape-level concern for those people?
When a disease like Ebola breaks out, sometimes an experimental drug is used, earlier than would normally happen. This is not because we are collectively giving in to greedy companies wanting to destroy all government regulation, it's because we recognize that the dire need for a solution sometimes outstrips the need for caution. Here is a recent example: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-05205-x
Do you disagree with this kind of response for serious disease breakouts, or does 40,000 deaths a year just not count as sufficiently dire? Would 100,000 breach that threshold? 500,000?
If the choice is between getting self-driving cars more quickly with minimal regulation -- which is what's happening right now -- versus much more regulation that will slow their development and introduction, it seems straightforwardly obvious that more people are likely to die in the status quo environment in the latter scenario than people die from testing in the former scenario. Companies would really have to go full Mad Max to kill even close to as many people as our current infrastructure and design kill.
> it logically and obviously extends to self-driving cars without any need for some onerous debate.
That's what I'm challenging, and I'm doing so on the basis that right now, things seem to be going fairly well. One person has died, which is very regrettable, but compared to the absolute mountain of corpses our usage of cars has created in general? It's obvious to me what's more important.
I guess I am saying this seems to be straightforwardly false to me, to a huge huge degree, and it worries me that people would naively use the rate of auto deaths under current circumstances as a justification to allow self-driving technology development to proceed unregulated.
It seems we just believe very strongly in positions that are completely and diametrically opposite to each other, so we are unlikely to find productive communication on a message board about it.
Why?
> It seems we just believe very strongly in positions that are completely and diametrically opposite to each other, so we are unlikely to find productive communication on a message board about it.
I mean, if you're not willing to explaining your reasoning, then yes I suppose that's true. Although I think part of why you may feel that way is that, based on one of your earlier comments, you seem to think I'm some kind of libertarian who's just generally opposed to regulation. I'm not; if anything I'm more of a social democrat. I just think that in this particular case, things are different from normal for a new, potentially dangerous technology.
My reasoning on the above point is fairly simple and straightforward:
1. The status quo for SDC development has been relatively minimal regulation. Even California mostly just makes companies report some basic data.
2. Most companies seem to be taking safety very seriously as it is, such that injuries and deaths have been rare. Only one death, and from a company widely acknowledged as ethically-challenged.
3. Given 2, it seems like the number of deaths that you'd avoid with greater regulation is very low, simply because, well, very few people are dying as it is.
4. Conversely, letting humans drive cars has resulted in an enormous number of people dying each year.
5. Given 3 and 4, slowing down SDC development with greater regulation seems likely to indirectly kill many, many more people than the status quo of minimally-regulated development will kill.
Are you expecting Waymo to, any day now, start rampaging around cities and killing people by the dozens? What does the scenario look like where SDC development kills more people than human drivers currently kill? You didn't address my analogy with disease outbreaks; why not?
You've done a good job arguing for the importance of regulation in general. You haven't done a good job arguing for why you think greater regulation in this particular scenario will avoid killing more people than the current setup kills.
Especially when the evidence from the current development of self driving cars is that a self driving car killing someone results in an entire testing programme to be suspended for months, possibly permanently, whilst the company is excoriated for taking unnecessary risks and is considerably less likely to develop a commercial application of SDVs as a result. It also shows that SDVs kill at a higher rate than non-SDVs even with human backstops, which is a much better test of whether they will actually save lives than "does a handful of test vehicles kill as many people as a few hundred million humans"
https://www.roadandtrack.com/new-cars/car-technology/a100168...
Giant vehicles are a bad idea, period. But they're no less bad for robots.
[1] 3000 deaths per day is 1.25 million annually, from https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic...
Edit: Uber’s program is a fiasco wrapped around a joke, but Waymo has taken an extremely careful approach and it’s a mistake to conflate the two.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epidemiology_of_motor_vehicle_...
> This makes motor vehicle collisions the leading cause of death among young adults of 15–29 years of age (360,000 die a year) and the ninth cause of death for all ages worldwide.
> It is estimated that motor vehicle collisions caused the deaths of around 60 million people during the 20th century,[6] around the same as the number of World War II casualties.
Approximately 1% of all deaths are in car incidents.
Why? Isn't the entire premise of a fully autonomous vehicle that you can get wasted and still hop in your own car and get home safely?
- the rate of traffic fatalities are unacceptably high
- the benefits of automobile usage far outweigh the costs, even with today's fatality rate.
The changes necessary to get fatalities completely down to zero would likely increase costs and reduce benefits too much. But reducing fatalities by an order of magnitude? Very feasible IMO.
This is by no means proven, and evidence suggests that it is wrong.
Cardiovascular disease is the number one cause of death, but I would still like some testing to be done on possible preventative measures before they're given to patients.
Don't forget the feedback loops. People use cars because they need cars, but they need cars precisely because they use them.
Have you ever left the city for a destination which is not another city, or a suburb?
Sure, if space ships were impossible or too expensive to even consider, we wouldn't be planning to visit Mars; but it isn't equally valid to not visit Mars altogether as an alternative to visiting Mars, just because going to Mars is harder than going to the corner store.
> Have you ever left the city for a destination which is not another city, or a suburb?
Sure. My point is not about vacations, or Mars trips, but precisely about regular commute. As more people started having long-range vehicles, the landscape of work and living spaces changed so that now people are required to have such vehicles, and if you don't have one, you're significantly disadvantaged on the job and residential markets. The same thing happened with cellphones, bank accounts, plastic cards - cool tools at first, and then soon requirements for living in modern society. I'm just pointing out this phenomenon for consideration.
I'll set aside for a moment how you seem to think that the only reason to leave the city is for a vacation. My point is that there is a tremendous benefit to people being able to choose precisely where they want to live and work, and that the car is the means to that end with the fewest limitations. More people could probably take mass routes in larger vehicles, especially if bicycle racks became larger and common enough to rely on, but that won't diminish the value of the car, even for a commute. Cities also seem dead-set on installing trams and subways, when buses clearly offer the best bang for the buck (but nobody likes to say that they ride the bus, probably because buses are unloved).
Personally I think the more effective route is to encourage less commuting altogether, which would be an obvious natural effect if the roads were on the market, but in practice it would have to take the form of a "credit". Some companies (e.g. Microsoft) have company shuttles, those could be encouraged as well (since roads are not on the market, and thus do not encourage pooling).