The comments almost always contained additional insight, knowledge or healthy pushback against the article they sat below. Much of what the user A. Andros wrote is a good example - https://www.economist.com/user/5518230/comments.
Vice did the same, as did The Guardian in some cases (on their 'comment is free' section, no less!).
Information invokes discussion. Just look at us here on HN. Removing readers' ability to discuss and question one's editorial stance is a bad, illiberal trend, and makes websites a little less worth visiting.
Oh yeah, and the popups are pants too. That screenshot is missing a mandatory GDPR and cookie notification btw. Somebody please inform the EU data protection czars.