I think you've hit the nail on the head there. I've been experimenting with writing my own shell and the original syntax was a lot more like Javascript but having to encapsulate parameters in parentheses, comma delimited and quotation was a
massive pain in the arse. So I dropped the requirement for quotation marks, then made commas optional, then I dropped using periods to pipe (ala methods in OOP) and then eventually ended up rewriting the entire parser to follow a more traditional POSIX syntax. As it turns out, as ugly as Bash et al is, it actually makes a lot of sense for writing one liners in an interactive shell (as you stated yourself)
So where I decided to deviate was areas I felt could be enhanced without breaking the POSIX syntax too significantly:
* shell configuration,
* error handling (something traditional shells are appallingly bad at)
* and support for complex data structures (eg so you can grep through items in a minified JSON array as smartly as you can with a traditional stream of lines.
I always respected the power of POSIX shells even before embarking on my pet project. However I never quite appreciated just how sane it's ugly syntax was until I attempted to replace it with something more readable. I mean sure there are still some specific areas I really don't agree with but that can always be argued as personal preference.
As an aside note, one thing I didn't quite appreciate until writing my shell is just how much shells have in common with functional programming. Yes I know it's a far cry from LISP machines; but if you take away the variable interpolation and environmental variables then you're left with a functional pipeline that take something from STDIN and write it to STDOUT and STDERR and does so in a multi-threaded, concurrent, workflow by default. Weirdly this still makes POSIX shells more efficient for some types of data processing than writing a monolithic routine in a more powerful (or should that be "more descriptive"?) programming language.
So there is some surprising elegance amongst all that ugliness.