We definitely do have real non-imaginary problems to focus on, but we shouldn't just ignore future problems. That's Hyperbolic discounting at its worst
Do you really think it's not worth thinking about the future and trying to predict problems that might occur, and preparing for them beforehand? Isn't not doing this one of the reasons we have real problems now? (Only some real problems, of course, others have nothing to do with this).
You're free to think about it if you like but don't be surprised if no one else shares your concern.
Unemployment is a prety bloody obvious problem that might occur if automation increases.
We also have historical data of jobs that have disappeared with various levels of success in retraining. This time there's legitimate and serious doubts that the employees affected by automation will be able to retrain at all, because several low-skill type of jobs that were retraining possibilities are also targeted by automation.
I completely agree!
The reason I think this is an issue with thinking about is:
1. Logic and common sense make a good argument for automation eventually replacing all jobs.
2. Most arguments against this amount to "historically this never happened even when people thought it would". This is a weak argument for several reasons (the period we're taking about is small, there's no reason to think history has to repeat itself here, etc).
3. Many smart people think this is a problem, including economists, including people from other fields.
If this doesn't make this problem worth thinking about, what does?
Meanwhile, we have real fucking problems right now:
1. Sky high housing prices. 2. Extreme wealth disparity. 3. Environmental degradation. 4. Cybersecurity failures everywhere, just as everything goes autonomous or otherwise cyberphysical. 5. Information operations threaten both democracy and the openness of the internet.
You can still make $100k a year editing English. The demand for talent is sky high, it's investments in education and society that will help us, not fretting over how AI will take away jobs long before we can do anything about it.
Wealth is moving around less because we don't need to spend (i.e. distribute) as much as we have in the past to generate more wealth. So, I think wealth disparity is a strong predictor for unemployment. I also think unemployment is the wrong word because it paints a false dichotomy. There's a not a huge lifestyle difference between making $20,000 a year and $0 a year (since the government steps in), compared to making $20,000 and $80,000 a year; and then $80,000 and $200,000.
One reason housing prices are so high right now is because people (mistakenly IMO) view houses as an investment. NO one wants to lose money on a sale. Another reason (for some areas) is probably because of the productivity gains. Since we need to distribute less to make more wealth, we've further centralized our economy into smaller pockets of land (i.e. cities).
So again, I think it's the same problem.
The only employers paying that much are old-school publishers that are a bit of a hold-out but will eventually give way. As a translator often doing full-length books, I have witnessed some big publishing names severely slashing the amount they pay for editing (by doing things like outsourcing the job to India), and they don’t worry about any drop in quality because it is felt that in a web-heavy world, the public no longer cares too much.
It is depressing as fuck for me as a translator, because I put a lot of effort into my translations and I wish they would get the same level of love at the next stage of the publishing process, but this is the trend of the future.
Also, I feel lucky to still have work as a translator because many clients today are running the text through Google Translate and then just paying a native speaker to clean up the text for less money than they would have to pay a translator. Obviously that is not common in the mainstream publishing world, but it is increasingly happening with the marketing materials and technical manuals that are a translator’s daily bread and butter. “AI” is already hitting businesses based on human language hard.
As for translation quality; I care. Others do too. though you're right that many don't. In the long run quality wins though.
And I don't agree that it's pure speculation - we do see how many jobs(in full or in part) could be, and may be on their way to being automated.
On the other hand, we rarely hear reasonable speculations on what would be the jobs that would replace them.
Considering the creativity of the human mind (and of various authors), and our love for speculation, that's somewhat worrying.
The burden of proof is not on the trend continuing, but on it slowing down for any reason.
Nobody can predict those numbers; any number about unemployment is essentially made up. And fallacious as well, according to the lump of labour fallacy.
In the meanwhile, the industrial revolution (of whom automation is part of), in its 200+ years, hasn't caused any death of political/economic/social systems.
This move towards automating thinking will not follow the same trend.
Communism was a direct response to the wealth inequality of the industrial revolution. That was one of the most disruptive political/economic/social upheavals of all time.
Hasn't it? It completely killed off mercantilism and mostly killed off monarchism.
Advances in politics made monarchies less relevant, not industrialization by itself, with France, the US and later Russia being the key examples. The US and Russia industrialized later than France and still-monarchies like the UK, Belgium, Denmark etc. Industrial giant Germany lost its king by losing a World War: despite industry, not because of it.
It not only killed off most pre-capitalist systems, it also mostly killed off the original system named “capitalism” (mostly in favor of modern mixed economies.) It also both spurred and then killed off Leninist Communism.
I do not think our society which has recently (and ongoingly) had someone work in one job function (often at one company) for 30+ years is ready for the fast paced change of needing to change jobs every few years.
Look at the rate of displacement in tech of technologies and frameworks. Try being an Angular developer for 20 years... I think people in software have come to expect rapid change because its the nature of the game, but that rate of change is unreasonable to be endured by every industry everywhere.
The pace is not increasing. There have been radical changes, as much as in the last few hundred years.
Two "poster children" of technological advancements (AI and nuclear) are always behind the corner, but never here. Even if they were here, there would be no catastrophe, as much as there hadn't been with green energy, and transistors.
> Look at the rate of displacement in tech of technologies and frameworks. Try being an Angular developer for 20 years...
This is irrelevant; Angular or not, the software engineering market is evergreen, even with poorly skilled software engineers (I do know some).
This example is actually a counterargument to the thesis: displacement of technologies in this field did not lead to displacement of jobs.
For example, can Siri or Alexa delete an specific phone number from a contact? Like "ok Google, delete home number from X" is not possible right now.