* Stranger Things
* Mindhunter
* Making a Murderer
* Orange is the New Black
* House of Cards
* Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt
* BoJack Horseman
For better or worse, all of these shows have as much staying power as the median HBO show, and most of them have more cultural currency. However good Barry might have been, TV critics weren't burning multiple columns talking about it.
And again, the idea that HBO just needs to compete with Netflix isn't my whole argument. Neither HBO nor Netflix picked up The Americans. HBO got outbid for a prestige show last year --- by Apple. The problem is that the prestige TV space is crowded.