I consult for VCs on a technical side and I sit in on many series A pitches. It’s funny how often when you ask a struggling startup why you, as a VC should invest millions into their business, they give the question like this back. “Why do you deserve to invest in my company?” “What are you as a VC bringing to the table?” “What kind of acceleration will you bring to my startup?”
The answer is “Millions of dollars in cash you just asked for” and in our minds we say “you stuck up asshole, you came to us.” At that point we often look for different investments. And we never go looking for companies to invest in. They always come to us.
That’s pretty arrogant. I can tell you from first hand experience that the best VCs are vigilant and don’t just expect people to get referred to them. a16z rates themeselves by the % of their competitor’s deals they had seen. You don’t optimize that number just from waiting for the phone to ring.
Unless you're one of the ~10 most well-known VCs in the world (or in your region/niche) it stands to reason that proactive search could yield additional high quality leads. Why forego this?
There's a parallel in recruiting: applicants on your web site might include many, many candidates who don't meet the minimum requirements of the role, such that even the top 10% include some that don't warrant a phone screen. So companies target passive candidates via LinkedIn, to find the gems who aren't currently even considering a new job.
(And it's not just small companies that do this. Even companies with a top-tier employer brand, which receive many thousands of applications, will actively source candidates this way.
Why doesn't the same apply to the VC firms with which you work (wrt potential investments)?
What I am sure of is that they don’t go looking for investments in the part of the fund I consult for. Those potential investments come to us in huge sets that many analysts have to narrow down into viable investment options.
Could it be better? Maybe. I mean they aren’t the largest VC in the world. Nor are they the smallest. But for a small number of partners they do quite well. I guess they like their methods. They would probably say if you have a different idea and the funds for your VC, by all means go for it.
In any event, the fact that beggars can't be choosers does not obviate the importance or utility of posing some form of the question to the prospective investor.
Some of the better questions I’ve heard are prefaced with comments like “we’re aware we’re having troubles in this operational area, would you be able to offer guidance and advice to get us out of this sticky situation?” Self awareness seems to be a sign of a great and investable company.