There is no easy solution to sustained ecological balance. Only by actively counteract the imbalance by positive action can a balance be maintained.
The problem is unfortunately very complex and in need of some large-scale, targeted effort.
The bycatch for sushi fish is even worse than the figure given in the article:
http://www.onegreenplanet.org/environment/sushi-obsession-is...
My marginal impact on the problem is negligible. The issue only manifests itself on a very large scale. Therefore, any solution involving "just stop eating fish" needs to explain a strategy to achieve this change of behavior on a large scale. Note that simply telling people on the Internet to change is not a working strategy - for each individual, again, the impact is marginal, but individual sacrifice required is great, so most people will just shrug and go on with their lives.
Want to make a change? Sure, stop eating fish if you want to signal your commitment. But don't stop at that, because at this point you've achieved nothing. Work to have more impact. Some particular bottom-up and top-down areas I can outline that mesh nicely together:
- Work to make the idea of not eating fish more popular. If you can convince a few hundred thousand people to stop eating fish, then maybe it'll actually show up somewhere on some spreadsheet in a fishing company. Be careful not to become like PETA though - if you're too hard about the topic, people will start eating more fish just out of spite.
- Make it easier for people to stop eating fish. That involves creating and popularizing new foodstuffs that are substitute to fish, but have better ecological footprint.
- The ultimate goal: work towards making the cost of fish products correctly account for externalities. That is, making them (much) more expensive. This involves finding ways to correctly estimate the costs of ecological impact, and then convincing regulators to make fishing industry pay this cost in taxes. Also, you'll want to fight various fishing subsidies that further hide the true costs. You'll make enemies along the way. But this is something that must happen, as it is the real solution. The previous two examples I gave are only supportive to this one. Fish must get more expensive. That's the efficient way of achieving a mass change of behaviour.
I'd love to see the animal agriculture industries forced to pay for their externalities but I doubt it's going to happen any time soon. But in the meantime a lot of positive change has come just from people being made more aware of where what they eat comes from and what it costs to get it there. Non-dairy milks have become so popular, for example, that they've put a huge dent in the dairy industry's profits.
The irony is, that the very same thing that's individually almost meaningless, is also the solution once everyone follows it. And there's a point in the middle somewhere, when the idea becomes popular - like vegetarianism today - and suddenly its impact becomes much greater than before. It gets noticed by the market, it starts flowing through feedback loops and begins affecting everything else. One person in a million refusing to eat fish is meaningless. One in a thousand starts to sound like a business opportunity, and business begets more business.
The trick is, how to get from here to there. Basically, how to start and sustain a movement.
I guess my whole point here is: if you care about a social problem then do your individual thing (here: stop eating fish). But don't stop there, try to do more. Try to speed up the change instead of just changing yourself and hoping others will follow. If we know anything about society, we know this: there are two primary motivators for changing behavior - things that impact one's sense of identity/ego, and things that impact one's wallet. Popularizing fish abstinence is an ego-based solution. Taxing the fishing industry is the economics-based one. We should pursue both.
They'd still be better off than the fishermen who are enslaved.
https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2018/02/01/582214032/wa...
Popularizing fish abstinence - now, that's an outline of a solution.
There is a lot of 'feigned indignation' in this world, and big plans whereby everyone has to change, and then we will see progress.
I couldn't give up fish, not right now. So I applaud anybody who would actually take that step, over writing a few bullet points as to how we should tackle the problem.
Even if I'm wrong saying that... how long will it take to reach critical mass? How much destruction will be caused attempting to reach it?
Individual-centered solutions can't work efficiently enough for these things to change without personal incentives. We need incentives, replacements, regulations.
Look at the difference between those two worlds:
World 1: "Don't use those free plastic bags! Buy a reusable bag instead for more money! It's the responsible thing to do!"
World 2: "Plastic bags cost $0.06 each."
Which one has less plastic floating in the sea?
But think of all the uplifting articles we'll have about new jobs on farms!
Or to put it another way: try not to contribute to creating a world you don't want to live in.
Why contribute to an industry where there is so much human slavery involved, still in 2018 (source - https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2018/jan/23/t...)?
I'm also upset by the large percentage of slaughtered animals that isn't eaten. Do you have an easy solution for me, just stop eating those species of animals?
I'm also upset by the large percentage of vegetables that's thrown away by the shops. Do you have an easy solution for me, just stop eating vegetables?
So... not so easy.