2) Giving (reportedly) one day notice that they are shutting down access is definitely a trust hit. They should have known long before that.
I don't use Instapaper and I'm not in the EU, but those of these points are raised elsewhere in this thread, and both seem valid concerns in terms of "trust" regardless of whether you approve/disapprove of the GDPR.
1. There was no certainty GDPR was going to pass.
2. There was no certainty as to what language would be used in the final document.
3. There was no certainty as to how/when it would be enforced.
By the time GDPR was actually passed, the lead time to enforcement was a slap in the face.
And to be honest, the compliance dates felt like a calculated attack to further the EUs moronic crusade against Facebook and Google, knowing full and well they were unrealistic deadlines.
Collateral damage to Instapaper and others is somehow a worthwhile trade off in the name of burning witches.
So I say, let there be consequences.