Hacker News Reader

Comment by readhn | Hacker News Reader

i find it hilarious that this is a 118 year old technology!

Ferdenand Porsche in 1900 presented a sportscar fitted with four electric wheel-hub motors, it was the first all-wheel drive passenger vehicle.

Where is the progress? The cars should have been flying by now.

View on HN

Physical limitations of batteries vs air oxidized fuel. Dragging around your own oxidizer takes a lot of mass which severely limits power.

The real breakthrough will be a battery that can use atmospheric oxygen, like a zinc-air battery. But it hasn't worked out in the last 100 years and it's not clear if it ever will.

i agree a significant breakthrough in batteries (or other energy sources) is needed.

Batteries appear to be operating on a vastly slower Moore's law at least. They have been sinfully underfunded as a research field historically.

It's not really a "Moore's law" thing at all - it's more that, like every single other technology in history that isn't specifically semiconductors, batteries don't follow an exponential improvement curve. They also evolve slower than many other technologies even on a more typical growth trajectory, because battery chemistry has way less room for easy improvement. There's only a few battery chemistries that could even theoretically offer much better density than lithium-ion, and we've been trying to make them work for a long time.

My bet is on graphene capacitor batteries.

I would bet on biodiesel for long distance highway transport, farm equipment, and other heavy industry; and electric in a bewildering array of form factors for short distance urban transport.

look at industrial metalworking from ~1860-1960 or so. It was close to exponential.

well at least one thing, the safety of modern cars is incredibly advanced.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com