(All three guidelines could certainly be challenged or have nuanced exceptions; this certainly isn't a straightforward issue.)
Edit: clarity
Bad ideas should be discussed publicly so that all can see the arguments against. Covering up/hiding such speech doesn't end that speech, it just makes sure that those who believe it never hear a refutation.
Do you think Facebook should allow paid antisemitic advertising on the platform?
https://boingboing.net/2015/11/06/facebook-is-censoring-link...
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2...
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/may/11/facebook-...
Free speech is a concept relating to the ability to articulate and express an opinion without fear of censorship or retaliation.
I do not put forward the position that my house allows free speech to everyone.
However, that person is well within their rights to go out into the streets and yell their positions at the top of their lungs. And I will support him in that. And I will decry any platform that purports to allow free speech but then censors a person.
But I'm also ok with someone creating a platform that doesn't allow for all speech. That falls under freedom of association.
Are you seeing just how complicated all of this is now?
Yes, you just repeated what I said.
I think you replied to the wrong comment :)
> Free speech relates to the government punishing or silencing people for what they say.
Versus:
> Free speech is a concept relating to the ability to articulate and express an opinion without fear of censorship or retaliation.
Do you think Facebook should allow paid antisemitic advertising on the platform?
What the government is allowed to do or not do with regards to speech is a First Amendment issue.
Facebook is dedicated to the overall principle of free speech. Which is different.
Facebook's definition of free speech is unclear and they change it when it suits their business needs. They are not as principaled as you make out. They are using it as an excuse to not deal with a problem that will cost them some time and money to solve.
You didn't answer my question. Do you think Facebook should allow targeted paid antisemitic advertising on the platform? Genuinely interested in what people think after Zuckerberg raised the issue.
Someone said that you shouldn't give a platform to someone who wouldn't extend the same courtesy.
Someone replied that it runs counter to the ideals of free speech that is one of the hallmarks of the country in which Facebook is based. They then asked why should Facebook lower their standards.
You then said that "Free speech relates to protecting people from the government punishing or silencing people for what they say". Which is wrong. Full stop.
The concepts of free speech apply everywhere. If you choose not to give a platform to certain viewpoints, you are not a place for free speech. But that is within your right on your own property. The concept is still valid, but you choose not to allow it.
So your question is meaningless.
They are trying to remain as free as possible while being respectful of all opinions, especially ones they disagree with. It is difficult. You want to go somewhere extreme because extreme example serve to demonize the side you don't like or to make it as obvious as you can.
But should Facebook allow targeted paid religious advertising? Should the allow targeted paid advertising for Scientology? Flat-earth? Anti-vaccine? Chiropractors? Fast food? Cigarettes? Alcohol?
Where is that line supposed to be drawn? And why there?
I'm not calling them principled. I'm saying the issue is messy and complicated. Something you refuse to acknowledge.
Can you answer the specific question about a specific topic (holocaust denial) that the CEO of the platform raised or is that case too messy?