This happened to me exactly one week ago. Three days after a very ordinary Sunday afternoon ride I got a ~$80 fee. I contested through the app and got a message containing two close-up pictures of a stained back seat. There was no background of the car, just a close-up of a seat cushion. The ticket was closed immediately after I received the picture. I was able to re-open it by replying to the email of the ticket I received, where I asked for proof of the time it occurred, or proof of anything really. I received a message acknowledging that I wanted proof, and then a generic summary of Uber's policy - once again the ticket was closed.
I am now adamantly not using Uber. Keep your $80 you lost a frequent customer.
Edit: FWIW this was for a ride from SF to RWC. Not in Miami.